REPORT on the Agenda for New Skills and Jobs

4.10.2011 - (2011/2067(INI))

Committee on Employment and Social Affairs
Rapporteur: Regina Bastos

MOTION FOR A EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT RESOLUTION

on the Agenda for New Skills and Jobs

(2011/2067(INI))

The European Parliament,

–       having regard to the communication from the Commission of 23 November 2010 on an Agenda for new skills and jobs: a European contribution towards full employment (COM(2010)0682),

–       having regard to its legislative resolution of 8 September 2010 on the proposal for a Council decision on guidelines for the employment policies of the Member States: Part II of the Europe 2020 Integrated Guidelines[1],

–       having regard to Council Decision 2010/707/EU of 21 October 2010 on guidelines for the employment policies of the Member States[2],

–       having regard to its resolution of 6 July 2010 on promoting youth access to the labour market, strengthening trainee, internship and apprenticeship status[3],

–       having regard to its resolution of 6 July 2010 on atypical contracts, secured professional paths, and new forms of social dialogue[4],

–       having regard to its resolution of 7 September 2010 on developing the job potential of a new sustainable economy[5],

–       having regard to the Council Conclusions of 6 December 2010 on ‘Employment policies for a competitive, low-carbon, resource-efficient and green economy’,

–       having regard to the study of the European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training (CEDEFOP) ‘Skills for Green Jobs’, 2010,

–       having regard to its resolution of ... October 2011 on promoting workers’ mobility within the European Union[6],

–       having regard to the Bruges Communiqué on enhanced European Cooperation in Vocational Education and Training for the period 2011-2020, which was adopted on the 7 December 2010[7],

–       having regard to the Medium-Term Forecast up to 2020: Skills Supply and Demand in Europe, European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training, 2010[8],

–       having regard to the CEDEFOP study of May 2009 entitled ‘Skills for Europe’s future: anticipating occupational skill needs’,

–       having regard to the framework agreement of 25 March 2010 on inclusive labour markets signed by ETUC, BUSINESSEUROPE, UEAPME and CEEP,

–       having regard to the communication from the Commission of 3 March 2010 on Europe 2020: a strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth (COM(2010)2020),

–       having regard to the communication from the Commission of 12 January 2011 on the Annual Growth Survey: advancing the EU’s comprehensive response to the crisis (COM(2011)0011), and the Draft Joint Employment Report annexed thereto,

–       having regard to the communication from the Commission of 23 February 2011 on the Review of the ‘Small Business Act’ for Europe (COM(2011)0078),

–       having regard to the communication from the Commission of 9 November 2010 on the conclusions of the fifth report on economic, social and territorial cohesion: the future of cohesion policy (COM(2010)0642),

–       having regard the Commission staff working document on ‘Progress Towards the Common European Objectives in the Education and Training’ (SEC(2011)0526),

–       having regard to the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and its entry into force in the Union on 21.01.2011, according to the Council Decision 2010/48/EC of 26 November 2009 concerning the conclusion, by the European Community, of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities[9],

–       having regard to the report by the European Association of Service Providers for Persons with Disabilities (EASPD) indicating that, with unemployment in Europe on the increase, it is becoming harder for people with disabilities to obtain and remain in work, and to the fact that in many countries the level of unemployment among people with disabilities is higher than that among non-disabled people,

–       having regard to the communication from the Commission of 21 September 2010 on Strategy for Equality between Women and Men 2010-2015 (COM(2010)0491),

–       having regard to the Council conclusions of 7 March 2011 on the European Pact for gender equality for the period 2011-2020,

–       having regard to the communication from the Commission of 3 October 2008 on a Commission Recommendation on the active inclusion of people excluded from the labour market (COM(2008)0639) and its resolution thereon of 6 May 2009[10],

–       having regard to Rule 48 of its Rules of Procedure,

–       having regard to the report of the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs and the opinions of the Committee on Industry, Research and Energy, the Committee on Regional Development, the Committee on Culture and Education and the Committee on Women’s Rights and Gender Equality (A7-0320/2011),

A.     whereas the global economic crisis has raised the unemployment rate in the European Union to a current 9.5 %, which represents 22 828 million people in total, of whom 19.4 % are long-term unemployed, according to recent EUROSTAT figures; whereas youth unemployment stands at 20.4 %, reaching as much as 40 % in some Member States,

B.     whereas SMEs, which are a driving force for economic growth, job creation and the achievement of the 2020 goals, have shed more than 3.5 million jobs as a result of the economic crisis,

C.     whereas as a consequence of the economic crisis of 2008, primary and manufacturing sectors lost more jobs than expected and are still projected to lose around 2.5 million jobs by 2020,

D.     whereas the economic recession of 2008 affected both skill demand and supply in the employment sector, thus increasing dramatically the uncertainty about job prospects and fostering the need for people to be better informed about employment prospects of the labour market,

E.     whereas austerity measures being pursued in a number of Member States have coincided with, and are partly responsible for, very significant increases in unemployment,

F.     whereas policy-makers need to protect citizens against the risk of unemployment, by ensuring that the workforce has the suitable skills to maximise its employability,

G.     whereas advances in new technologies and changes in the structure of the European economies have made it indispensable for individuals to update and ameliorate their skills during their working life,

H.     whereas the promotion of a social, resource-efficient, ecological and competitive economy is one of the objectives of the Europe 2020 strategy,

I.      whereas the service sector, such as sales, security, cleaning, catering, caring and personal services, is still expected to provide substantial job growth between now and 2020 and could be the fastest growing area,

J.      whereas the agrifood sector is regaining global importance requiring different and higher level skills but strongly reducing low skilled jobs,

K.     whereas achieving sustainable growth and the transition to low carbon economy, environment protection and development of new green technologies will require availability of appropriate skills,

L.     whereas technological change and new patterns of work organisation in sectors naturally influence the employment patterns in terms of skills needs in occupations and qualification levels,

M.    whereas economies increasingly demand creative, interactive, communication and problem-solving skills in the workplace while low-skilled jobs or workers performing routine functions are at major risk of loss of employment,

N.     whereas workers with a low level of education and skills, in addition to those from other vulnerable groups, are at greater risk of loss of employment, precarious conditions and poverty unless they are provided with appropriate training and retraining possibilities that enable them to keep pace with labour market requirements,

O.     whereas the long-term effectiveness of training and higher education depends on various things, such as availability of quality education and training provision, equal opportunities and barrier-free access for all, availability of care services, sustained public investment, the state and efficient management of public finances, and better articulation of individual and labour market needs,

P.     whereas the EU has undertaken to improve education levels, to reduce the school drop-out rate to less than 10 % by 2020 and to increase the rate of completion of tertiary or equivalent education to at least 40 %,

Q.     whereas the number of jobs demanding high-level technical and scientific qualifications is expected to rise, and around half of all jobs in 2020 will be for workers with medium-level qualifications, while 35% of jobs will require high-level qualifications, as compared to 29 % today, and whereas additional qualifications for a sustainable economy will be required across all occupations and in all skill segments,

R.     whereas migration, within, as well as into and out of, the EU, and demographic change will in many ways influence the future size and composition of the working population in Member States and have important implications for skill demand and supply, especially in those Member States in which the population is rapidly declining or which are subject to large-scale brain drain,

S.     whereas the competences and skills of migrant workers are often neither properly recognised nor made the best use of, and whereas migrant workers often face difficulties in accessing the labour market, education and training, also because of the lack of knowledge of their labour and social rights and their lack of involvement in workers' associations; whereas integration policies which favour access to education, training and employment for the immigrant population can therefore make an important contribution to meeting future labour market needs,

T.     whereas, even though microcredit is a vital tool for female entrepreneurship and the creation of family businesses, women remain underrepresented in business in the European Union, representing an average of 30% of all entrepreneurs,

U.     whereas over 60 % of students graduating from universities are women, whereas not enough women and girls go into science, leading to severe gender segregation by sector, and whereas the gender gap between women and men’s employment in the IT sector has tended to widen rather than narrow over time,

V.     whereas women are in a disadvantaged position in the labour market and are disproportionately represented in part-time work and in new, often precarious, forms of working arrangements, facing obstacles in seeking access to full social rights, social protection and benefits,

W.    whereas sustainable economic growth has the potential to increase the number of decent jobs and to contribute to recovery of economies across the EU,

X.     whereas the EU still invests less than its world economic partners and competitors, in research, innovation and education, which are cornerstones for growth and improvement of living standards; whereas major investments are needed in the know-how economy, in technical training and in upgrading vocational training,

Y.     whereas targeted and adapted up-skilling is essential to help people acquire new skills so that they can profit from the transition towards a more sustainable economy; whereas there are convincing economic arguments for up-skilling, labour market integration and social inclusion; whereas reducing investment in up-skilling will create a negative long-term impact,

Challenges facing employment policies

1.      Recalls that, within the Europe 2020 strategy, Member States agreed on an employment target of 75 % for men and women in the 20-64 years age group by 2020, a goal closely connected with economic growth and sustainability of social security and public finances in Europe; recalls that the employment rate for women currently stands at 58.2 %; underlines that a drastic reduction of youth unemployment, increased women's participation in the labour market and effective implementation of the inclusion priority of the strategy are among the vital preconditions for reaching the employment target; stresses that most National Reform Programmes fall short of meeting both the employment and the poverty target, and calls on all stakeholders to intensify their efforts to make the Europe 2020 strategy a success;

2.      Reiterates that the five Union headline targets are promoting employment, improving the conditions for innovation, research and development, meeting climate change and energy objectives, improving education levels and promoting social inclusion;

3.      Recalls the existence of major obstacles to substantially raising employment in the EU, combating structural unemployment and creating new jobs and thus boosting productivity and fostering greater competitiveness; believes that the challenges to be tackled as a matter of priority, in addition to ensuring better-functioning labour markets, include the mismatch and insufficient skill levels of many workers today, as well as the low rankings in education levels in some European countries, compared to international rates; considers that an integrated approach to developing the necessary skills base will be vital in making the most of the potential of a new sustainable economy, and calls on the Commission, in its planned communication on jobs in the new sustainable economy, to follow up on Parliament’s requests in this respect;

4.      Points out that the employment rate and economic performance are mutually reinforcing in generating particularly high levels of economic growth and quality employment; strongly recommends, however, that the Member States follow the Europe 2020 integrated set of guidelines for employment policies and broad economic policy guidelines, while making sure that the policies put in place respond to national, regional and local circumstances and particular conditions in individual Member States;

5.      Stresses that Member States are still in charge of key elements of social policy such as taxes, social welfare programmes, some labour regulation, healthcare and education; considers it essential that social policies respond to national, regional and local circumstances and particularly conditions in individual Member States;

6.      Calls for better coordination of economic policies among Member States in order to foster sustainable growth and job creation and to facilitate effective competition, taking into account the regional inequalities across Europe regarding employment and unemployment rates; urges Member States to respect the rules on budgetary discipline in order to diminish the risk of falling into excessive deficit and calls for effective budgetary surveillance, while allowing for public investment in line with the EU’s growth and employment objectives; emphasises, however, the importance of the social impact assessment as required by the Treaty and urges the Commission and the Member States to assess the social costs of spending cuts, in particular of those for education and active labour market policies which could jeopardise progress in addressing the shortage of skilled workers in Europe and maintaining economic performance;

7.      Supports the Commission's flagship initiative within the Europe 2020 strategy as a framework to promote competitiveness and employment and to make the change towards a sustainable, smarter and more inclusive economy; highlights the importance of the regional dimension in implementing the agenda; calls on the Commission to deliver on the employment and skills priority actions under the flagship initiative, giving appropriate importance to promoting both labour supply and demand in the context of a knowledge-based, sustainable and inclusive economy;

8.      Considers that the Agenda for New Skills and Jobs should be seen in conjunction with the EU’s Research Framework Programme, and that synergies between the two could create growth and jobs;

9.      Stresses that recent economic and labour market developments combined with future challenges, such as demographic change and transition to a sustainable economy, call for better employment, education and work organisation strategies in order to improve the competitiveness of the EU and the working and living conditions and to create new jobs, and therefore to promote 'smart growth' combining full employment and welfare, as well as sustainable production and lifestyles; underlines in that connection the importance of universal access to lifelong learning, qualifications and skills for all age groups; stresses the economic arguments for up-skilling, labour market integration, social inclusion, effective combating of discrimination and better utilisation of the assets of all workers; recalls that work-life balance, education and improvement of human capital also have non-economic benefits for the individual;

10.    Stresses that national flexicurity arrangements must be reviewed in the light of the new socio-economic contexts, maintained, where appropriate, strengthened and adapted to the specific needs of each individual Member State, in order to ensure a flexible, inclusive and active labour market, efficient training accessible to all, and adequate social security systems; calls on the Member States to accompany their labour market reforms with strengthening poverty-proof social and unemployment protection and improving the quality of public employment services; stresses that flexicurity should not be perceived as a one-size-fits-all solution;

11.    Stresses the importance of informal and skills learning through strengthening of intergenerational cooperation, when young people can acquire new skills through teaching by experienced older workers;

12.    Regrets that for many workers the reconciliation of work and family life remains a difficult task; calls on the Member States to give all parents, especially women, single-parent families, disadvantaged or disabled people opportunities for integration not only into working life but also into lifelong learning processes; stresses, as a prerequisite, that organisation of work and training possibilities should be made compatible with parental responsibilities, that childcare structures should be made more effective and accessible and that appropriate support should be provided for parents; calls, furthermore, on Member States to put in place policies and programmes to support family carers;

13.    Considers it advisable to promote an environment conducive to teleworking wherever such arrangements can foster an appropriate work-life balance;

Responses

Ensuring the availability of a skilled labour force

14.    Welcomes the establishment of the European Employment Observatory and the Commission's initiatives to produce an EU Skills Panorama and to reform the European Employment Service’s EURES network in order to improve transparency and access for jobseekers and to promote job mobility in the EU; stresses the key role of EURES in advising mobile workers and jobseekers as regards their rights and therefore in delivering on a genuine internal market, and welcomes the launch of the pilot project "Your first EURES Job" aimed at young jobseekers in the EU-27; highlights, furthermore, the role of EURES in cross-border regions and considers that its cross-border partnerships need to be provided with the necessary resources to be able to answer to the challenges of the European labour market;

15.    Stresses the importance of increasing participation in life-long learning, in particular in vocational education and training with a view to ensuring employability, and upgrading the skills of the workforce and to strengthening competitiveness; points out that the proportion of people in further education should also be increased so that people with higher qualifications can find and perform suitable jobs into old age; considers in this context that incentives should be provided for both employees and employers, with particular focus on SMEs; considers also that more comprehensive lifelong learning strategies need to be put in place and that vocational education and training systems need to be tuned to the rapidly changing needs of the labour market, technological development and new approaches to the organisation of work;

16.    Regrets the fact that at a time of crisis Member States have reduced their education and training budgets, and urges the Commission and the Member States to invest more in education and training systems;

17.    Calls for better monitoring in each professional sector and, according to qualification level, of the upcoming skill demand in Europe and for an immediate transposition of the findings into education, lifelong learning and other relevant policies of the Member States; emphasises the importance of boosting the attractiveness of jobs and careers to young workers and that young people in particular must be kept informed at all times about labour market trends so that they can concentrate on developing skills which are actually needed; considers that a ‘knowledge alliance’ that brings together businesses, social partners and education institutions would be a useful instrument in addressing innovation and skills gaps, contributing significantly to promoting the interests of the economy and society as a whole, especially considering the critical challenge of attaining full employment, poverty eradication, social inclusion and sustained economic growth in the global economy;

18.    Stresses the importance of early identification of skill needs, suggesting at least a 10-year time horizon, and calls on the Member States and, where warranted, the regions to set up employment monitoring centres focusing on future needs; stresses furthermore the importance of developing more reliable systems for the anticipation of future skill needs and skill shortages in the EU and Member States, as well as the importance of continued investment in skills upgrading and better matching of qualifications to jobs; reiterates the need to ensure that the public have access to qualitative information and calls for exchange of experience and best practice in that regard; to accomplish this, emphasises the need for stronger, more effective cooperation between education and training providers, including universities and research centres on the one hand, and public employment services, the social partners and enterprises and employers on the other hand;

19.    Emphasises the need to raise the profile and attractiveness of professions and jobs for which there is a workforce deficit on the labour market;

20.    Calls on the Commission to give more visibility and financial support to the Leonardo da Vinci programme, which enables people to acquire new skills, knowledge and qualifications, and which makes vocational education more attractive to everyone; points out, furthermore, that on-the-job training is particularly important, and calls for support for national schemes that promote these kinds of career development opportunities;

21.    Notes that the Erasmus sub-programme has an implementation rate of close to 100%; recalls the well-documented evidence that Erasmus considerably facilitates study abroad and provides students with a wider range of skills, and that this, in turn, significantly improves subsequent employment prospects for those students participating in Erasmus and thereby contributes substantially to Europe’s competitiveness;

22.    Emphasises the importance of a high-quality State education system which guarantees everyone free, equal access;

23.    Believes that is vital to create an environment for close cooperation between research institutes and industry and to encourage and support industrial companies in investing in research and development; recalls that higher education institutes and training bodies play a key role in the regional economies of Member States and that they are unique places where innovation, education and research come together and can lead to job creation, development of entrepreneurial and other skills and to more employment opportunities; recognises the role of the University-Business Dialogue initiative in this context; calls on local and regional authorities to promote the European Eco-Management & Audit Scheme (EMAS) and to encourage all economic sectors to strive to achieve EMAS registration;

24.    Calls on the Commission to promote further the establishment of European Sector Councils for Employment and Skills within the context of the "Agenda for New Skills and Jobs", which should be upheld as a platform for collection and exchange of information held by Member States and regions in order to help coordinate the efforts of all parties concerned, as well as as a tool to support social dialogue activities;

25.    Considers it essential to substantially boost investment in education, research and innovation, and accordingly takes the view that, in order to encourage Member States to move in this direction, special consideration should be given to public spending on education, research and innovation when Member States' medium-term budget objectives are assessed;

26.    Notes that instruments such as surveys of the job profiles and occupations required in different sectors – conducted on the basis of social partnership – must therefore receive adequate support;

27.    Calls on the European Social Dialogue Committees to assist in better matching existing training to present and future demand through a road map setting out clear objectives and indicators for monitoring progress;

28.    Stresses the need to involve employers in the management of education institutions and in the development of courses, teaching methods, apprenticeships, assessment and qualification; underlines the importance of incentives for employers who offer training for low-skilled or unskilled people and, consequently, of opportunities to acquire practical experience directly in the workplace;

29.    Regrets that the number of early school-leavers still remains too high in the EU; points out that a reduction of only 1 % in the number of early school-leavers could bring some 500 000 potential workers onto the labour market; calls therefore on the Member States to implement more effective policies, based on high-quality, modern education and vocational training, to prevent early school leaving and remove barriers to remaining in education, to offer learning and training alternatives and retraining possibilities to students with learning difficulties or disabilities and to develop effective links between initial training and the world of business; underlines the importance of early education for developing not only the future functional skills of people, but also their capacity to learn, to specialise and to develop further, and calls for the development of a coherent, holistic, long term approach to early childhood education and care as proposed in the relevant Commission Communication;

30.    Finds it regrettable that many people with disabilities who are capable of working are not integrated into the labour market, and calls on the Member States to implement policies that offer alternatives with regard to education, training and employment for people with disabilities;

31.    Calls on the Member States to support publicly funded and properly regulated institutions of initial education, covering pre-primary, primary and secondary schools, vocational training and tertiary education, with well qualified and well trained teaching and support staff on good pay and conditions;

32.    Emphasises the importance of public education systems accessible to all and in line with the promotion of equal opportunities for all;

33.    Welcomes the Commission’s proposal to promote European centres of excellence within new academic specialisations for tomorrow’s jobs and to improve the mobility of young people in this area; underlines the importance of creating the conditions necessary for the growth of clusters of innovative enterprises which can act as a decisive spur to local economic development and can create new jobs in regions; considers that, as the pace of economic restructuring increases, a skilled workforce, managerial expertise, innovation, science, technology and green jobs are all prerequisites for sustainable growth;

34.    Encourages Member States to integrate ICT competences, digital literacy, entrepreneurship and transversal key competences such as communication in foreign languages and competences for personal fulfilment and development, active citizenship, creativity, cultural awareness and intercultural understanding, as well as key competences relating to environment, climate change and sustainable development, into all levels of educational systems; stresses in this regard the importance of promoting and recognising both ‘hard’ and ‘soft’ skills to improve people’s employment opportunities; points to the usefulness of the ability to communicate in foreign languages, and supports language learning and the development of language teaching;

35.    Underlines the need for education aimed at innovation; stresses that non-schematic and abstract thinking should be promoted, as well as the technical education needed to match the needs of the future;

36.    Stresses that efforts should be made to ensure that all children develop fundamental IT skills at an early age, that IT should therefore be included in primary school education and that all Europeans should have cheap and easy access to the internet;

37.    Given that it is estimated that in 2015 there will be a shortfall of IT professionals extending to between 384 000 and 700 000 jobs, while the estimated deficit for the health sector is of some one million professionals and that for researchers another one million, calls on the Commission and the Member States to take measures to ensure the necessary level of skilled human resources in these fields;

38.    Notes that the internationalisation of education is of social, cultural and economic significance, and consequently urges the Commission to facilitate international mobility among researchers, students, scientists and lecturers, both within and outside the EU;

39.    Expresses concern that highly qualified individuals are accepting employment beneath their abilities or unskilled jobs, leading to ‘brain waste’ in the EU;

40.    Urges the Member States to develop training programmes for teachers that will provide them with a basis on which they can better adapt to changes on the labour market and develop the corresponding skills at all levels of education;

41.    Encourages Member States to promote workplace-based training, including a dual system of education/training, in order to introduce young people to the labour market from the earliest stage, and to promote a quality framework for internships and apprenticeships leading as much as possible to stable employment; furthermore, calls on relevant stakeholders to ensure that traineeships and apprenticeships are carried out under the supervision of professional tutors, that they lead to the acquisition of real skills and experience corresponding to labour market needs and to the provision of new jobs; invites the Member States to lay down minimum standards for traineeships as regards pay and social rights, and calls for the introduction of a European quality framework for traineeships, setting up decent working conditions and rules to prevent trainees from being used to replace regular employment;

42.    Calls on the Commission and Member States to reinforce an evidence-based policy exchange on the transition from education and training to work and on learning mobility, which contribute to the development of the skills and the employability of young people;

43.    Urges the Commission, in the forthcoming legislative initiative on professional qualifications, to strengthen the mutual recognition of diplomas and professional qualifications and to move towards a mechanism for enhanced mutual recognition of competences and skills, including skills acquired through informal and non-formal training, as well as to extend the mechanisms for recognition to workers from third countries; considers that this mechanism should build on appropriate European frameworks, such as the European Qualifications Framework (EQF) and the European Credit system for Vocational Education and Training (ECVET);

44.    Calls on national statistics services to develop adequate indicators for measuring skills and the quality of the various levels of their education system;

45.    Takes the view that the External Action Services (EAS), particularly the EU delegations in third countries, could play an important role by providing information on the skills required in Europe and the jobs available, as well as assisting in the procedures necessary for coming to Europe;

46.    Notes that as a result of demographic change there is a significant number of older potential volunteers, which is a huge untapped resource in our communities; calls on the Commission to promote opportunities for older volunteers, and to develop a Seniors Action Programme for the increasing number of very experienced senior citizens who are willing to volunteer, which might run in parallel with, and complement, the Youth in Action Programme, and furthermore to promote specific programmes for intergenerational volunteering and for mentoring;

47.    Believes that, in the context of the strategy for prolonging active life, not enough is being done to help older people acquire IT skills, and urges the Commission and the Member States to develop broad-based educational programmes for this group;

48.    Emphasises the need to maintain the craft tradition and its associated skills and to establish strategies for craft retail entrepreneurs, in order to maintain the cultural identity of the craft sector; draws attention, in that connection, to the importance of supporting work-linked professional training and the mobility of young craftsmen and women; notes that the promotion of traineeships as a means of integrating young people into this sector may be an active policy worth encouraging and calls on the Member States to take the appropriate steps in that regard; stresses the importance of the humanities as a field for investigating the past and better preserving cultural identities;

Promoting demand for labour and job creation

49.    Draws attention to the fact that small and medium-sized enterprises play their part in the European economic fabric owing both to their number and to their strategic role in combating unemployment; recalls that SMEs provide 85 % of jobs in the EU and are responsible for 58 % of all the added value created in the Union; urges all relevant stakeholders to remove all measures likely to hinder business creation and its free movement; calls on the Member States and the Commission to facilitate the establishment and stimulate the growth of small and medium-sized enterprises, paying special attention to women's entrepreneurship, to provide them with a favourable regulatory and fiscal environment, to facilitate market access, to list the barriers to recruitment, to reduce the level of bureaucracy to a minimum and to improve their access to finance;

50.    Considers that a more targeted use of innovation and a more competitive industrial base are necessary in order to boost employment; considers it necessary to promote youth employment, R&D-based business models and specific incentives for the recruitment of a wider range of job-seekers;

51.    Welcomes the Commission proposal to introduce in future a simplified procedure for issuing employees of a firm who are third-country nationals with a temporary residence permit valid throughout the EU;

52.    Calls on the Commission and the Member States to invest more in job creation and to promote entrepreneurship, business start-ups and self-employment in order to create employment opportunities and to reduce social exclusion; is of the opinion that a proper environment and incentives for business development as well as support for the introduction of new technologies are important but not enough for the development of European economies; stresses, therefore, that more focus should be placed on promoting entrepreneurial mindsets and skills at different education levels, coaching for new entrepreneurs and effective skill development for SME staff; underlines the role of the European Institute of Technology and the EIB, in particular of programmes such as JASMINE and JEREMIE, in fostering business creation and development and in providing support for SMEs’ needs;

53.    Calls on the Commission to observe the Think Small First principle and take the needs of SMEs into account when drawing up employment legislation;

54.    Stresses the importance of a free and intelligently regulated internet for new entrepreneurs and job creators; considers that internet users’ confidence in the system and their trust that its integrity will not be compromised is crucial for new internet business models;

55.    Points out that the European Union does not have enough R&D intensive innovative firms and that the serious lack of skills in innovation and digital literacy means that SMEs cannot adopt innovative smart business models and new technologies;

56.    Urges the Commission and Member States to continue to cooperate with a view to creating an integrated and competitive risk capital market, which is vital for the creation and growth of innovative SMEs;

57.    Considers that a barrier-free and competitive single market must be completed in order to facilitate free movement of workers; considers furthermore that the completion of the single market should go hand in hand with labour legislation that creates a level playing field, strong coordination of social security and the ability of workers to preserve, maintain or transfer their acquired rights, in particular portability of pensions, across borders; in this regard, calls on the Commission and Member States to work closely with the social partners to eliminate obstacles to students' and workers' mobility and to encourage sharing of best practice and experience in this area in order to assess how the internal market is developing in terms of social security for wage-earners and in the light of the pay and working conditions in the host country; emphasises in that connection that wage dumping should be prevented;

58.    Strongly condemns undeclared work, which endangers both society and workers; calls on the Member States to carry out regular and more numerous checks, to impose appropriate penalties, and to initiate information campaigns in order to raise awareness of the rights of workers and the long-term disadvantages for those employed in the black economy; invites, furthermore, the Member States to combine preventive measures and sanctions with incentives aimed at avoiding resorting to undeclared work and at transforming undeclared work into regular employment;

59.    Considers that the health-care sector has a critical role to play in achieving the goals of the Europe 2020 strategy; furthermore considers that, because of demographic change, the health and social care sector represents a source of employment, whose significance will grow, and a key contributor to social inclusion; calls for the development of a care economy to meet real needs and to ensure high quality accessible care services for all, good working and pay conditions to avoid resorting to undeclared work; calls on the Commission to support the ILO convention supplemented by a recommendation on domestic workers in order to improve the working conditions for workers in this sector; calls on the Commission to initiate a study on care assistants employed in clients’ homes, in addition to other appropriate and sustainable solutions which support independent living, in order to establish whether EU legislation provides sufficient social protection for this category of workers which are often women;

60.    Stresses the potential of social, health, care and education services to create new employment and demands a strong and sustainable investment in these key services and infrastructures as well as decent working conditions to support quality service provision; looks forward to the Commission’s action plan to address the gap in the supply of health workers;

61.    Calls on the Commission, Member States, social partners and other stakeholders to ensure efficient, simplified and synergetic use of EU funds, such as ESF, ERDF and the Cohesion Fund, and facilities such as the Microfinance Facility, for job creation, including in the social economy; highlights the advantages of gearing structural fund investment towards education and training in technologically high value-added sectors and towards sectors that are particularly important for encouraging the transition to more sustainable growth models; calls for particular consideration to be given to those Member States with high unemployment and an average monthly income that is below the poverty threshold;

62.    Stresses the importance of synergies between the various European funds and underlines the importance of a decentralised approach when using these funds in order to respond to labour market requirements; believes that there is also a need to give individuals and enterprises suitable incentives to invest in training; in this regard, highlights the contribution of cohesion policy to the resource-efficient Europe flagship initiative and calls for its potential for sustainable growth to be considered;

63.    Agrees with enhancing the impact of the cohesion policy instruments, including the ESF, by focusing on concentrating financial resources on a smaller number of priorities, strengthening conditionality for institutional reforms, reinforcing the partnership principle, emphasising clear and measurable targets and establishing development and partnership investment contracts between the Commission and the Member States;

64.    Calls on the Commission to review the existing framework of EU direct enterprise support schemes and to study the possibility of allocating the lion’s share of the support to job creation in enterprises, developing workers’ skills and implementing further training programmes;

Improving the functioning of the labour market

65.    Notes that flexicurity policies are put at the centre of the New Skills and Jobs Agenda, and shares the Commission’s assessment that the crisis has put national flexicurity arrangements to a serious test, including where external flexibility measures have been introduced in the labour markets without corresponding strengthening of social security systems; stresses, however, the need to pursue labour market reforms without undermining successful policies and consensus and trust between national governments and the social partners; emphasises that flexicurity measures must be tailored to social circumstances and the specific structure of national labour markets and be consistent with the interests of employers and workers;

66.    Stresses, however, that flexicurity alone cannot remedy the crisis and calls on the Commission, the Member States and the social partners to pursue the necessary labour market reforms, paying special attention to labour market integration of workers from vulnerable and disadvantaged groups; recommends in this context that a bottom-up approach be taken in order to facilitate dialogue and involvement of all levels of political and social governance;

67.    Believes that, under the new momentum of social and economic changes, the four pillars of flexicurity – flexible and reliable contractual arrangements, active labour market policies, lifelong learning, and modern social security systems – and the balance between them should be reviewed and reinforced in order to respond to the needs of workers and companies in modern labour markets, to create decent jobs and to ensure employability of workers, adequate social protection and the respect of the principle of "equal pay for equal work" in conjunction with gender equality; considers the strengthening of labour market institutions essential throughout this process in order to ensure that workers benefit from transitions between jobs, occupations, sectors and employment statuses; considers furthermore that the social partners should play a role in that review, as part of social dialogue;

68.    Calls on the Commission, pursuant to Article 152 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, to step up promotion of the role of management and labour in each industrial sector across Europe, while respecting their autonomy;

69.    Supports, pursuant to Article 155 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), dialogue between management and labour and encourages them to enter into contractual relations, including agreements; recommends that in implementing agreements concluded at European level, management and labour in each industrial sector use the procedure laid down in Article 155(2) TFEU for matters covered by Article 153 TFEU;

70.    Urges the Member States to develop teleworking, i.e. all forms of distance working and all kinds of work organisation and/or execution which exist outside the classic time-space format, by means of telecommunications and the Internet, in the form of a service provision or an employment relationship;

Promoting inclusive labour markets

71.    Underlines that, in order to emerge stronger from the economic crisis, to become more competitive and convergent, with higher levels of growth and employment, and to secure our welfare systems in the long term, Europe needs to make better use of its labour force potential in all age groups, to improve both functioning of its labour markets and social inclusion and social protection, as well as to boost the qualifications and skills of the labour force;

72.    Emphasises in this context that reducing labour market segmentation has to be achieved by providing adequate security for workers and improving labour market inclusion in order to increase the opportunities for all workers under different forms of contracts, in particular those in the most disadvantaged and vulnerable groups, to enter and make progress in the labour market;

73.    Stresses the importance of mainstreaming the rights of persons with disabilities in the implementation of the Agenda, as well as in all aspects of the Europe 2020 strategy; calls upon the Commission to take appropriate measure to promote development of and access to universally designed goods and services as enshrined in Article 29 of the UN CRPD, including exchange of best practices;

74.    Stresses that pay rises do not keep pace with productivity gains in many Member States, and is extremely concerned at the growing number of ‘working poor’, who, although earning a wage, remain below the poverty line, and believes that resolute action should be taken to remedy this situation;

75.    Emphasises the importance of tackling youth unemployment as a matter of priority; calls on the Commission and Member States to continue their efforts to foster youth integration in the labour market, including the provision of incentives for young people and employers and the development of traineeships and apprenticeships; underlines in this context the crucial importance of facilitating the transition from school to work, personalised guidance and monitoring, as well as of providing opportunities to acquire real skills and to upgrade them in line with labour market requirements; emphasises that this initiative must be closely coordinated with the ‘Youth on the Move’ initiative;

76.    Emphasises the importance of creating appropriate conditions to ensure that older workers can stay longer in the labour market and of mainstreaming intergenerational solidarity and cooperation within the employment context and the implementation of initiatives promoting longer working lives such as job sharing, skills and career re-appraisal, employee volunteering and phased retirement, including among those who are freelancers;

77.    In view of the ageing of Europe’s population, calls on Member States to create a set of instruments to facilitate labour market access for older people, and calls both for promotion of, and wide support for, guidance and activation of older people in the light of the innovation partnership Active and Healthy Ageing as well as for incentives for employers, given that business is less interested in older workers; stresses the importance of such persons’ receiving further training and gaining new qualifications that will enable them to re-enter the labour market; in this context, stresses the importance of making use of the knowledge and experience of older people, e.g. through coaching projects;

78.    In the light of rising unemployment, calls on the Member States to modernise and strengthen the public employment services in order to play a greater role as lifelong service providers to both workers and employers; believes that public employment services can offer facilities for evaluating skills, establishing profiles and providing individual career guidance and consultation services, in close cooperation with local employers, as well as provide information on entrepreneurship opportunities and a range of training and re-training programmes;

79.    Urges the Commission and Member States to officially recognise the contribution made by the social economy, which is responsible for 10 % of jobs in the EU and plays a key role in the EU's economic, social and territorial cohesion; considers it necessary to step up its development in order to contribute to socially inclusive wealth creation and to help to develop inclusive labour markets, to retain jobs in sectors and businesses in crisis and/or threatened by closure, to increase job stability levels, to keep skills alive and to develop routes into work for groups that are especially disadvantaged;

80.    Emphasises that better and stronger policies promoting gender equality and the reconciliation of work, family and private life should contribute to increased participation of the active population of women and men in the labour market; stresses the importance of empowering women to enter, re-enter and advance in the labour market, in particular those who face difficulties with returning to work after maternity or parental leave;

81.    Takes the view that efforts must be made to promote technical and engineering studies such as MINT (mathematics, informatics, natural sciences, technology) among girls and to combat gender stereotypes and professional segregation of women in education and labour market; calls on the Member States to take targeted measures to increase the number of women in senior management and other leading positions;

82.    Considers that EU anti-discrimination legislation has considerably raised the level of protection across the EU; believes, however, that more needs to be done to tackle discrimination, including multiple discrimination, of different groups in employment, training and occupation with a view to putting into effect the principle of equal treatment; believes that greater involvement of women in the labour market should also be fostered by means of targeted welfare policies focusing on childcare and family support, by implementing gender mainstreaming programmes, as well as by measures promoting recruitment of women and men to non-traditional jobs on a voluntary basis, with special attention being paid to traditionally male-dominated sectors;

83.    Points to the economic arguments for anti-discrimination besides the human rights dimension; calls on Member States to take the necessary steps to swiftly conclude agreement and adopt the proposal for a Council directive on implementing the principle of equal treatment between persons irrespective of religion or belief, disability, age or sexual orientation; calls on the Commission to continue supporting overcoming technical difficulties within the Council in order to reach such agreement as a strong EU anti-discrimination policy will underpin the 2020 strategy;

84.    Maintains that, if the qualifications and skills of female workers are to be preserved in a changing economic space and those who so wish are to be helped to return to work, it is essential that workers on parental leave should also be included in the training activities organised by their employer;

85.    Calls on the Commission and the Member States to support measures for reconciliation of professional and family life, and to invest in women’s labour market participation through promotion of diversity management, professional encouragement of women and promotion of the creation of new posts with more flexible forms of working conditions;

86.    Stresses that new jobs should be accompanied by new forms of working arrangements that will enable workers with dependent children to work alternative hours, reduce their working time or opt for teleworking;

87.    Notes that opportunities to raise the rate of women’s employment are offered not only by the ‘white-job’ sector but also by the home defence sector, the logistics sector (including transport), the business services sector – insurance and consulting, for example – and the ecological sector and sustainable jobs;

88.    Urges the Commission and Member States to support and develop specific programmes geared to recruiting women to technical professions through subsidies for young female academics, in line with best practice in certain Member States such as the ‘Excellentia’ programme in Austria, which has made it possible to double the number of female S&T university professors and has contributed to the establishment of high-quality research centres led by women;

89.    Calls on the Commission and the Member States to encourage the private and public sector to take all possible and necessary action to eliminate the gender pay gap and the major inequalities in terms of access, pay, career development, participation and governance, with the aim of improving women’s participation in the labour market; stresses, in this connection, the importance of transparency in the form of better statistics, and of a usable definition of ‘work of equal value’; welcomes the Commission’s announcements on reviewing the pension system for those with gaps in pension-saving contributions due to periods of unemployment, sickness or caring duties, which concern mainly women;

Improving job quality and working conditions

90.    Considers that pursuing the objective of full employment has to be complemented by strengthened efforts to improve the job quality, working and living conditions of all employees, including health and safety at work and gender equality;

91.    Considers that job quality has to be promoted as a multidimensional concept, covering both employment relations and work itself; calls on the Commission to step up efforts to review the EU definition and common indicators of job quality, to make them more operational for the evaluation and benchmarking of Member States’ policies; considers that social dialogue plays an important role in promoting decent work, quality employment and adequate social protection and thus calls on the key stakeholders in the field of industrial relations at EU level to work towards developing a common European approach in this area and to take an active part in the review of the definition and indicators of job quality;

92.    Considers that workplace accessibility, especially in relation to the built environment and information technologies, is an essential working condition and one that is crucial to the vocational integration of people with disabilities;

93.    Welcomes the Commission proposal of reviewing health and safety legislation and warns that insecure working environment, constant changes from one job to the next, and increasing stress have negative effects on workers physical and metal health; asks the Commission to address the problem of lack of recognition of job related hazards and illnesses;

94.    Emphasises the importance of integrating stakeholders’ efforts to improve job quality and the use of appropriate policy instruments, including legislation, policy coordination, exchange of good practice and autonomous agreements of the social partners;

95.    Is of the opinion that the high number and increasing proportion of occupational illnesses, in particular the spread of musculo-skeletal disorders, has a significant impact on the quality of workplaces, so that greater effort must be made to reduce these if the ageing society is to be sustainable;

96.    Considers that workers rights, dialogue between the social partners - workers and employers - and adequate social protection preventing in-work poverty should be at the core of employment quality and thus also of the job quality concept;

97.    Encourages the Commission to complete its pre-legislative activities and put forward the legislative proposals announced in the Agenda, fully respecting the outcome of its economic and social impact assessment and the autonomy of the social partners; welcomes the Commission’s plans to review the effectiveness of the legislation concerning job quality and working conditions, taking due account of developments;

98.    Underlines that the goals set in the field of employment and the strategies to achieve them should be monitored and coordinated with those in other important areas, such as the public finance sector and the relevant innovation policies;

99.    Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Council, the Commission and the Governments and Parliaments of the Member States.

• [1]  Texts adopted, P7_TA(2010)0309.
• [2]  OJ L 308, 24.11.2010, p. 46.
• [3]  Texts adopted, P7_TA(2010)0262.
• [4]  Texts adopted, P7_TA(2010)0263.
• [5]  Texts adopted, P7_TA(2010)0299.
• [6]  Texts adopted, P7_TA-PROV(2011)0000 (Report A7-0258/2011 - vote in Plenary in October I 2011).
• [7]  Commission Press Release IP/10/1673.
• [8]  CEDEFOP publications, ISBN 978-92-896-0536-6.
• [9]  OJ L 23, 27.1.2010, p. 35
• [10]  OJ C 212E, 5.8.2010, p.23.

EXPLANATORY STATEMENT

The economic, financial and social crisis now affecting Europe has pointed up the weaknesses of the European economic and social model, and has invalidated certain aspects of the progress achieved earlier.

Since the first effects of the crisis made themselves felt on the labour markets in 2008, Europe has lost 5.6 million jobs.

There are currently 23 051 million unemployed in the EU, accounting for 9.5% of the active population, with grave implications for growth and welfare in Europe.

Equally disturbing are the difficulties encountered by some employers in recruiting staff, especially for highly skilled posts. Even during the crisis, certain employers were finding it hard to find people with suitable skills for the vacancies to be filled.

Reinforcing human capital and employability by means of updating skills will mean placing Europe on the path of recovery.

We need to offer people the right incentives to help them update their skills, articulate education and training more closely with work, develop a suitable mix of aptitudes and more effectively anticipate what skills will be needed in future to ensure a better supply-demand fit on the labour market.[1]

The Member States have set the ambitious objective of a 75% employment rate for the 20-64 age group by 2020.

The EU is capable of rising to this challenge, and has the potential to improve employment rates substantially.

In November 2010 the Commission adopted a draft communication entitled ‘An agenda for new skills and jobs: a European contribution towards full employment’.

This ‘agenda for new skills and jobs’ is part of the Europe 2020 strategy, representing the Commission’s contribution towards achieving the Member States’ ambitious goal of 75% employment for the 20-64 age group by 2020.

With a view to attaining this goal, the Commission proposes an action centred on four priorities:

•       further labour market reform aimed at achieving both more flexibility and more security (‘flexicurity’);

•       suitable incentives for individuals and companies to help them invest in training and ensure the ongoing updating of people’s skills in line with labour market requirements;

•       proposals to be presented by the Commission with a view to ensuring decent working conditions while also improving the quality of labour legislation: there will be a review of the working time directive, as well as a legislative initiative to improve the directive on the temporary posting of workers;

•       action to ensure labour market conditions that are friendly to job creation, inter alia by cutting administrative burdens and taxes related to labour and mobility, recalling that this is an especially important aspect for sectors in process of rapid change, e.g. those characterised by intensive recourse to R&D.

Your rapporteur, while in agreement with the Commission’s approach, believes there is room for improvement, especially as regards the following:

•       the reduction of administrative burdens and red tape for SMEs in order to create jobs;

•       school drop-out rates, recalling that it is for the Member States to take preventive action and offer pupils alternatives in the field of training and apprenticeship;

•       measures to improve the work-life balance;

•       improved monitoring and anticipation of necessary skills for the future, thus permitting a closer match with supply and orienting the development of skills in terms of enhanced prospects of employment over a lifetime;

•       measures targeted on young people with a view to their integration on the labour market even before they have finished formal education, in particular by means of traineeships leading to new job opportunities;

•       the need to strengthen the rules on flexicurity and adapt them to the socio-economic context of each Member State, in order to ensure a flexible labour market, proactive policies in relation to that market, lifelong learning and modern welfare systems;

•       the need to improve the directive on the temporary posting of workers, with a view to cutting red tape and resolving double taxation issues, in order to facilitate the free movement of workers;

•       the need for further progress on the mutual recognition of qualifications as between the EU and third countries;

•       closer cooperation between educational institutions and the world of business.

If we are to devise effective policies for employment, education and training and facilitate individuals’ career choices, we will need to improve the capacity of the Member States and the Union to forecast and anticipate the nature of future skills and ensure that they are in line with labour market needs.

• [1]  On the subject of supply and demand in respect of skills in Europe, see: ‘Skills supply and demand in Europe. Medium-term forecast up to 2020’, Luxembourg, 2010: http://www.cedefop.europa.eu/EN/Files/3052_en.pdf

OPINION of the Committee on Industry, Research and Energy (1.9.2011)

for the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs

on the Agenda for New Skills and Jobs
(2011/2067(INI))

Rapporteur: Niki Tzavela

SUGGESTIONS

The Committee on Industry, Research and Energy calls on the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs, as the committee responsible, to incorporate the following suggestions in its motion for a resolution:

1.  Welcomes ‘An agenda for new skills and jobs’ as part of the 2020 strategy, bearing in mind that Europe needs specific targets and concrete measures in order to work towards common goals in terms of creating jobs and promoting sustainable and inclusive growth, which can be achieved only by coordinated responses among Member States;

2.  Welcomes the Commission’s recognition of the need to promote entrepreneurship and self-employment; is of the opinion that the establishment of a proper environment and incentives for creating and sustaining businesses is crucial, but not enough for the development of the European economy; stresses, therefore, that proper training in entrepreneurial skills is needed at both the middle and the higher education levels in order to ensure that Europe does not lag behind other actors; underlines the role of the European Institute of Technology in fostering business creation and development through innovation-driven research and a strong emphasis on entrepreneurship;

3.  Welcomes the Commission’s first priority of giving a new impetus to flexicurity by strengthening its four components: flexible and reliable contractual arrangements, active labour-market policies, lifelong learning and training and modern social security systems;

4.  Calls on the Member States and, where warranted, the regions to set up an employment monitoring centre focusing on future needs so as to anticipate the latter and provide qualifications that will maximise the likelihood of finding employment, particularly for young people;

5.  Reiterates that the five Union headline targets are promoting employment, improving the conditions for innovation, research and development, meeting climate change and energy objectives, improving education levels and promoting social inclusion;

6.  Stresses that employment policy is an area of national competence and that labour markets are structurally different;

7.  Underlines that more focus should be placed on promoting entrepreneurial mindsets among students and researchers, making available new financial instruments for start-ups and fast-growing firms and supporting the introduction of successful technologies on the EU market;

8.  Calls on the European Social Dialogue Committees to assist in better matching existing training to present and future demand through a road map setting out clear objectives and indicators for monitoring progress;

9.  Draws attention to the Commission’s finding that the new technologies and developments in work organisation seem to result in a significant expansion in jobs at both ends of the job spectrum;

10. Regrets the fact that at a time of crisis Member States have reduced their education and training budgets, and urges the Commission and the Member States to invest more in education and training systems;

11. Draws attention to the lack of progress in reducing the numbers of people who, despite being employed, are living under the poverty threshold; calls on the Commission and the Member States to promote quality jobs that are well paid and offer secure and healthy working conditions;

12. Points out the importance of the proposed comprehensive life-long learning suggestions and the emphasis that has to be put on integration of ICT competences and digital literacy (e-skills) into core lifelong learning and education policies, in order to overcome the serious deficit in qualified personnel, such as ICT practitioners and researchers, which threatens to undermine the future economic competitiveness of the EU;

13. Stresses the need to involve employers in the management of education institutions and in the development of courses, teaching methods, apprenticeships, assessment and qualification; underlines the importance of incentives for employers who offer training for low-skilled or unskilled people and, consequently, of opportunities to acquire practical experience directly in the workplace;

14. Points to the fact, also recognised by the Commission, that significant investment in green skills need to be made in order to ensure that Europe meets its 2020 objectives for green-collar workers and to ensure that its economic system can operate in a more sustainable way and thus remain competitive in the future;

15. Underlines the need for education aimed at innovation; stresses that non-schematic and abstract thinking should be promoted, as well as the technical education needed to match the needs of the future;

16. Stresses that efforts should be made to ensure that all children develop fundamental IT skills at an early age, that IT should therefore be included in primary school education and that all Europeans should have cheap and easy access to the internet;

17. Calls on the Commission to support the ‘Knowledge Alliances’ in order to develop new training programmes that will bridge innovation skills gaps and meet job market needs;

18. Notes that, in order to achieve the goals of EU 2020, the Member States’ response to the demands of industry in terms of the workforce needed must be more flexible;

19. Believes that, in the context of the strategy for prolonging active life, not enough is being done to help older people acquire IT skills, and urges the Commission and the Member States to develop broad-based educational programmes for this group;

20. Calls on the Commission and the Member States to strengthen the provision of vocational education and training across Europe in order to help provide the new skills needed in the labour market;

21. Observes that labour mobility among EU countries remains low, and calls on the Commission to consider the establishment of a pan-European service to direct the skilled labour force to vacant posts across Europe, supporting a labour market of European added value. In this context, urges the Member States to eliminate the barriers to free movement of workers and calls for the full implementation of the 2012 Single Market projects proposed by the Commission; underlines the importance of a broader strategy combining job creation, meeting new and emerging needs on the European labour market, and eliminating labour restrictions inside the EU and the remaining barriers within the EU internal market;

22. Supports the Commission’s proposal that European Sector Councils on employment and skills should be established to collect information held by the Member States and the regions in order to help coordinate the efforts of all parties concerned;

23. Stresses the need further to match skills with labour market needs; welcomes the Commission’s initiative in this matter;

24. Given that it is estimated that in 2015 there will be a shortfall of IT professionals extending to between 384 000 and 700 000 jobs, while the estimated deficit for the health sector is of some one million professionals and that for researchers is another one million, calls on the Commission and the Member States to take measures to ensure the necessary level of skilled human resources in these fields;

25. Underlines the importance of SMEs and their contribution to job creation, and welcomes measures such as cutting down red tape designed to help in the setting up of new businesses. Highlights the important role that the EIB could play, in particular by fostering programmes such as JASMINE and JEREMIE, which can provide sustainable support for SMEs’ needs; stresses the need to provide support for SMEs not only with finding people with the right skills but also with upgrading their skills; notes that in the context of the roadmap toward a resource-efficient Europe, SMEs needs support with upgrading their competences in terms of sustainable development and research and innovation;

26. Is of the opinion that SMEs can play, and are playing, a very important role in training both in highly specialised, innovative sectors and in those that require the basic manual skills needed for many services; notes that there is therefore a need for close cooperation between SMEs and educational establishments; takes the view that facilitation of financial assistance for internships and practical training in the SME sector should also be considered;

27. Stresses the importance of a free and intelligently regulated internet for new entrepreneurs and job creators; considers that internet users’ confidence in the system and their trust that its integrity will not be compromised is crucial for new internet business models;

28. Points out that the European Union does not have enough R&D intensive innovative firms and that the serious lack of skills in innovation and digital literacy means that SMEs cannot adopt innovative smart business models and new technologies;

29. Stresses that current labour market trends in any given Member State are influenced by structural issues in that country, and that initiatives at European level should consequently take national specificities into consideration;

30. Calls on the Commission to observe the Think Small First principle and take the needs of SMEs into account when drawing up employment legislation;

31. In the face of rising unemployment, calls on the Member States to step up staffing levels in employment offices in order to deal with the increasing numbers of job seekers; believes that public employment offices can play a greater role as lifelong service providers, offering facilities for evaluating skills, establishing profiles and providing training, individual professional guidance and consultation services for clients (both workers and employers);

32. Calls on the Commission, pursuant to Article 152 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, to step up promotion of the role of management and labour in each industrial sector across Europe, while respecting their autonomy;

33. Considers that the Agenda for New Skills and Jobs should be seen in conjunction with the EU’s Research Framework Programme, and that synergies between the two could create growth and jobs;

34. Supports, pursuant to Article 155 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), dialogue between management and labour and encourages them to enter into contractual relations, including agreements; recommends that in implementing agreements concluded at European level, management and labour in each industrial sector use the procedure laid down in Article 155(2) TFEU for matters covered by Article 153 TFEU;

35. Stresses the importance of partnerships at regional and local level that bring together public services, education and training providers and employers, from the viewpoint of reducing unemployment at regional and local level;

RESULT OF FINAL VOTE IN COMMITTEE

Date adopted	31.8.2011
Result of final vote	+: –: 0:	43 0 7
Members present for the final vote	Jean-Pierre Audy, Bendt Bendtsen, Jan Březina, Maria Da Graça Carvalho, Giles Chichester, Pilar del Castillo Vera, Christian Ehler, Lena Ek, Ioan Enciu, Vicky Ford, Gaston Franco, Norbert Glante, Fiona Hall, Jacky Hénin, Edit Herczog, Romana Jordan Cizelj, Krišjānis Kariņš, Lena Kolarska-Bobińska, Philippe Lamberts, Bogdan Kazimierz Marcinkiewicz, Marisa Matias, Judith A. Merkies, Angelika Niebler, Jaroslav Paška, Aldo Patriciello, Miloslav Ransdorf, Herbert Reul, Teresa Riera Madurell, Michèle Rivasi, Paul Rübig, Konrad Szymański, Michael Theurer, Britta Thomsen, Patrizia Toia, Evžen Tošenovský, Claude Turmes, Niki Tzavela, Vladimir Urutchev, Kathleen Van Brempt, Alejo Vidal-Quadras, Henri Weber
Substitute(s) present for the final vote	Francesco De Angelis, Satu Hassi, Jiří Havel, Marian-Jean Marinescu, Alajos Mészáros, Vladko Todorov Panayotov, Mario Pirillo, Silvia-Adriana Ţicău, Lambert van Nistelrooij

OPINION of the Committee on Regional Development (18.7.2011)

for the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs

on the agenda for new skills and jobs
(2011/2067(INI))

Rapporteur: Monika Smolková

SUGGESTIONS

The Committee on Regional Development calls on the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs, as the committee responsible, to incorporate the following suggestions in its motion for a resolution:

1.  Welcomes the agenda for new skills and jobs as part of the EU 2020 strategy, pointing to the need for increasingly high skills, as only a workforce that is skilled is of fundamental importance for the development of a competitive, sustainable and innovative economy, and considers that development policies should be created geared to upgrading the system for science and innovation, promoting improved employability, growth and social cohesion so that the agenda for new skills and jobs will adapt to the post-crisis period and prevent the recurrence of such a crisis in the future; in this context, underlines the importance of concrete and consistent measures for the training of the workforce;

2.  Supports the promotion of integrated approaches involving the main players at national, regional and local level; in this context highlights the importance of the regional dimension in implementing the agenda for new skills and jobs; takes the view that the participation of the European regions will help to make the agenda a genuine success and calls for this dimension to be strengthened;

3.  Stresses the need to improve and diversify employment services for both jobseekers and employers and, in particular, to develop personalised public employment services for the unemployed, young people and vulnerable groups;

4.  Calls for greater attention to be paid to the issue of reducing unemployment among young people, many of whom are very well educated and highly qualified but are unable to find jobs owing to factors such as a lack of experience, and calls for real and effective action to be taken towards this end; points out that this situation could result in long-term distortion of the EU labour market;

5.  In view of the ageing of Europe’s population, calls on Member States to create a set of instruments to facilitate labour market access for older people, and calls both for promotion of, and wide support for, guidance and activation of older people in the light of the innovation partnership Active and Healthy Ageing as well as for incentives for employers, given that business is less interested in older workers; stresses the importance of such persons’ receiving further training and gaining new qualifications that will enable them to re-enter the labour market; in this context, stresses the importance of making use of the knowledge and experience of older people, e.g. through coaching projects;

6.  Draws attention to the fact that female unemployment is rising, affecting even women who are highly qualified and highly skilled, and calls on the Commission to seek to ensure that women and men have equal opportunities on the labour market;

7.  Highlights the need to ensure the more effective use of funds for the development of new skills and greater participation by national governments in boosting the creation of new jobs, including in the burgeoning ‘green economy’; stresses that the social economy can be used as a means of creating jobs for the less-favoured social groups, which involves principally a mobilisation of funds and programmes: the European Social Fund (ESF), the European Regional Development Fund, the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD) and the Lifelong Learning, Progress and INTERREG programmes;

8.  Stresses the importance of synergies between the various European funds and underlines the importance of a decentralised approach when using these funds in order to respond to labour market requirements; believes that there is also a need to give individuals and enterprises suitable incentives to invest in training; in this regard, highlights the contribution of cohesion policy to the resource-efficient Europe flagship initiative and calls for its potential for sustainable growth to be considered;

9.  Welcomes the launch of the pilot project ‘First job - EURES’, aimed at young jobseekers in the 27; believes that this project should involve local authorities and organisations responsible for young people’s integration, irrespective of their social or geographical origins;

10. Agrees with enhancing the impact of the cohesion policy instruments, including the ESF, by focusing on concentrating financial resources on a smaller number of priorities, strengthening conditionality for institutional reforms, reinforcing the partnership principle, emphasising clear and measurable targets and establishing development and partnership investment contracts between the Commission and the Member States;

11. Supports policies designed to promote job creation taking into account - as a priority - the needs of small and medium-sized enterprises, which provide two thirds of all jobs in the private sector, and takes the view that training mechanisms, to which the private sector should also contribute and which are tailored to their needs, should be created; advocates innovative measures for creating new skills, especially in the context of SMEs;

12. Calls on the Commission to review the existing framework of EU direct enterprise support schemes and to study the possibility of allocating the lion’s share of the support to job creation in enterprises, developing workers’ skills and implementing further training programmes;

13. Attaches vital importance to effective incentives and cost-sharing schemes with the aim of increasing public and private investment in the systematic training of workers and in Lifelong Learning focusing on ICT and digital literacy, to language learning and to developing planning, analysis, organisational, problem-solving and communication skills and the ability to adapt to new situations; underlines the importance of improving people’s access to ICT irrespective of their place of residence and social situation;

14. Believes that support for private enterprise in the R&D context will generate new jobs and enable the development of new skills in response to market needs;

15. Stresses that the exchange of experience and best practices and the creation of networks and coordination mechanisms at national and EU-wide level between higher education institutions, research establishments and business centres is essential for raising skill levels and adapting to the needs of the labour market; emphasises the need to consolidate employers’ networks and encourage exchanges of best practices among them; insists on the importance of a stable supply/demand balance between employers and training institutions; calls on local and regional authorities to promote the European Eco-Management & Audit Scheme (EMAS) and to encourage all economic sectors to strive to achieve EMAS registration;

16. Welcomes the Commission’s proposal to promote European centres of excellence within new academic specialisations for tomorrow’s jobs; underlines that, especially in urban areas, regional and local authorities are the best placed and most capable of creating the conditions necessary for the growth of clusters of innovative enterprises; points out that such clustering can act as a decisive spur to local economic development and can create new jobs in regions;

17. Points out that the main responsibility for achieving the aims of the agenda for new skills and jobs lies with the Member States and their regions, and that it is therefore essential for the Commission to ensure that the aims of the agenda are adopted by each Member State;

18. Calls on the Commission to adopt measures to remove administrative and legal obstacles in order to increase labour mobility, by means both of the recognition of qualifications and of the portability of supplementary pension rights; stresses the need to boost workforce mobility between EU Member States as a potential means of reducing regional imbalances and fulfilling the objectives of cohesion policy; welcomes the Commission’s initiative to reform the European Employment Services (EURES) network in order to improve services for mobile workers and jobseekers, particularly in border regions;

19. Calls for national, regional and local actors to be involved in the processes of assessing, adapting and defining changes in the agenda’s implementation;

RESULT OF FINAL VOTE IN COMMITTEE

Date adopted	12.7.2011
Result of final vote	+: –: 0:	42 3 1
Members present for the final vote	François Alfonsi, Luís Paulo Alves, Charalampos Angourakis, Catherine Bearder, Victor Boştinaru, Zuzana Brzobohatá, John Bufton, Alain Cadec, Francesco De Angelis, Tamás Deutsch, Rosa Estaràs Ferragut, Elie Hoarau, Brice Hortefeux, Danuta Maria Hübner, Juozas Imbrasas, Elżbieta Katarzyna Łukacijewska, María Irigoyen Pérez, Seán Kelly, Mojca Kleva, Petru Constantin Luhan, Riikka Manner, Iosif Matula, Erminia Mazzoni, Miroslav Mikolášik, Lambert van Nistelrooij, Franz Obermayr, Jan Olbrycht, Markus Pieper, Monika Smolková, Georgios Stavrakakis, Nuno Teixeira, Michael Theurer, Michail Tremopoulos, , Oldřich Vlasák, Kerstin Westphal, Hermann Winkler, Joachim Zeller
Substitute(s) present for the final vote	Andrea Cozzolino, Karima Delli, Ivars Godmanis, Karin Kadenbach, Marek Henryk Migalski, Vilja Savisaar-Toomast, Elisabeth Schroedter, Derek Vaughan
Substitute(s) under Rule 187(2) present for the final vote	Norica Nicolai

OPINION of the Committee on Culture and Education (14.7.2011)

for the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs

on the Agenda for New Skills and Jobs
(2011/2067(INI))

Rapporteur: Katarína Neveďalová

SUGGESTIONS

The Committee on Culture and Education calls on the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs, as the committee responsible, to incorporate the following suggestions in its motion for a resolution:

1.  Points out that investing in education and training and forecasting skills needs are crucial if the Europe 2020 strategy commitment to improving education levels, i.e. reducing school drop-out rates to 10% or less and increasing completion rates for tertiary or equivalent education to at least 40%, is to be met;

2.  Deplores the disproportionately high rate of youth unemployment in the EU; notes that youth unemployment has detrimental effects on social cohesion, equity and growth; calls on the Commission and Member States to work together to prioritise the implementation of active labour market policies to tackle this crisis;

3.  Stresses the vital importance of guaranteeing equal, universal access to high-quality state education and to lifelong learning so that individuals can develop socially and intellectually and acquire the skills they need to enter working life;

4.  Emphasises the importance, in order to achieve these objectives, of integrated pathways between education, training and work with a view to the gaining of professional and educational qualifications, and the need for initiatives in the area of adult education and the refreshing of basic skills; calls on the Member States, with a view to involving those groups that are in the weakest position because they are the least well educated and qualified, to develop nationwide careers advice services that can provide relevant information about training and educational opportunities, along with individual skills assessments;

5.  Recognises the importance of the contribution that must be made by vocational training in enabling a significant number of young people to realise their potential as well as achieving the objectives of the Europe 2020 strategy;

6.  Considers that the measures proposed in the Commission communication will require strong policy coordination; therefore urges Member States, and particularly their relevant ministries, to become more closely involved in the process of early identification of skills needs, suggesting at least a 10-year time horizon; strongly believes that, when education and training programmes are being designed, effective communication and cooperation between employers, social partners, educational institutions and training bodies are necessary, using specific mechanisms to identify labour market needs; reiterates the need to ensure that the public have access to qualitative information in that regard; calls on Member States to incorporate into their education, training and lifelong learning programmes the teaching of cross-cutting skills relating to the use of ICTs, artistic expression, mobility, democratic participation and multiculturalism; stresses, with that aim in view, that it is essential that the competences and skills acquired by means of informal and non-formal education should be recognised and exploited;

7.  Notes that instruments such as surveys of the job profiles and occupations required in different sectors – conducted on the basis of social partnership – must therefore receive adequate support;

8.  Notes that the EU’s labour force must become more skilled, so as to be able to contribute and adapt to technological change and new approaches to the organisation of work; calls on the Member States to invest more heavily in education and training systems, to anticipate skills requirements, to align supply and demand and to provide careers advice services;

9.  Welcomes the establishment of the European Employment Observatory and recognises that the creation of online career mobility tools, such as ‘EU Skills Panorama’, that provide clear information on job opportunities could help future workers to choose a career path and acquire the right mix of skills, such as ICTs and languages, thus boosting their job prospects and adaptability; strongly believes that forecasting in this regard should have a 10-year time frame;

10. Takes the view that closer links between the education and business worlds could help to identify correctly the abilities required at a given moment, and could subsequently facilitate young people’s entry onto the employment market;

11. Recalls that higher education institutes and training bodies play a key role in the regional economies of Member States and that they are unique places where innovation, education and research come together and can lead to job creation; points out that strong cooperation between faculties within universities, universities themselves, other higher education institutions and training bodies, regions, governments, civil society stakeholders, particularly the social partners, and business is fundamental to Europe’s economic and social development; recognises the role of the University-Business Dialogue initiative in this context;

12. Notes that the internationalisation of education is of social, cultural and economic significance, and consequently urges the Commission to facilitate international mobility among researchers, students, scientists and lecturers, both within and outside the EU;

13. Expresses concern that highly qualified individuals are accepting employment beneath their abilities or unskilled jobs, leading to ‘brain waste’ in the EU;

14. Emphasises the need to maintain the craft tradition and its associated skills and to establish strategies for craft retail entrepreneurs, in order to maintain the cultural identity of the craft sector; draws attention, in that connection, to the importance of supporting work-linked professional training and the mobility of young craftsmen and women; notes that the promotion of traineeships as a means of integrating young people into this sector may be an active policy worth encouraging and calls on the Member States to take the appropriate steps in that regard; stresses the importance of the humanities as a field for investigating the past and better preserving cultural identities;

15. Considers that measures should be implemented for setting up a system of informal workplace-based training, e.g. a system of apprenticeship, inter alia within traditional crafts and professions, in order to make the acquisition of new skills and jobs more accessible and to promote diversification of the labour market;

16. Emphasises the need to raise the profile and attractiveness of professions and jobs for which there is a workforce deficit on the labour market;

17. Calls on the Commission to give more visibility and financial support to the Leonardo da Vinci programme, which enables people to acquire new skills, knowledge and qualifications, and which makes vocational education more attractive to everyone; points out, furthermore, that on-the-job training is particularly important, and calls for support for national schemes that promote these kinds of career development opportunities;

18. Notes that the Erasmus sub-programme has an implementation rate of close to 100%; recalls the well-documented evidence that Erasmus considerably facilitates study abroad and provides students with a wider range of skills, and that this, in turn, significantly improves subsequent employment prospects for those students participating in Erasmus and thereby contributes substantially to Europe’s competitiveness;

19. Points out that the ability to communicate in foreign languages is considered important for all EU citizens and regarded as a useful skill on the labour market; therefore encourages this literacy requirement and supports language learning and the development of language teaching, particularly in the context of in-service training, including acquiring communication skills in languages that are less internationally widespread and less used;

20. Takes the view that there is insufficient emphasis on the potential of migrants from non-EU countries to meet the needs of the labour market;

21. Takes the view that non-academic, technical higher education is a key sector when it comes to linking skills acquisition with the needs of businesses and economic growth and productivity targets;

22. Acknowledges that higher education institutions and training bodies have the potential to prepare people for the world of work: for instance, SMEs with no R&D facilities can benefit from university research resources and expertise, and SMEs can offer students high-quality internships and apprenticeships, which enable them to build on their education and significantly increase their employment opportunities; calls, therefore, for the strengthening of cooperation between higher education institutions, training bodies and SMEs, giving students the opportunity to acquire and develop entrepreneurial skills; notes the role played by cultural and creative industries in providing an appropriate learning and training environment;

23. Calls for exchanges of experience and for the presentation and promotion of best practice in relation to improving employability and education for actual labour market demand;

24. Underscores the importance of lifelong learning as the continued building of skills and knowledge throughout an individual’s life, and in further enhancing social inclusion, personal development and active citizenship;

25. Calls for stronger support for, and recognition of, both formal and non-formal education as integral parts of the lifelong learning process;

26. Stresses the importance of green jobs as new jobs for the current global market, with a view to preserving and restoring environmental quality;

27. Calls on Member States to work steadily and closely on eliminating administrative and legal obstacles to students’ and workers’ mobility as well as recognising degrees and qualifications;

28. Urges an effort to achieve the full integration of disadvantaged groups into the employment process, including with regard to searching for the right kinds of job for people with disabilities, who often have unique or exceptional skills;

29. Highlights the persistent gender discrimination in certain fields of employment and certain positions, and calls for the elimination of differences of treatment between men and women and for an end to the gender stereotyping of certain jobs;

RESULT OF FINAL VOTE IN COMMITTEE

Date adopted	14.7.2011
Result of final vote	+: –: 0:	23 2 0
Members present for the final vote	Magdi Cristiano Allam, Zoltán Bagó, Lothar Bisky, Piotr Borys, Jean-Marie Cavada, Silvia Costa, Santiago Fisas Ayxela, Mary Honeyball, Petra Kammerevert, Morten Løkkegaard, Emma McClarkin, Marek Henryk Migalski, Katarína Neveďalová, Doris Pack, Chrysoula Paliadeli, Marie-Thérèse Sanchez-Schmid, Marco Scurria, Hannu Takkula, László Tőkés, Helga Trüpel, Milan Zver
Substitute(s) present for the final vote	Heinz K. Becker, Ivo Belet, Nadja Hirsch, Seán Kelly, Iosif Matula, Georgios Papanikolaou
Substitute(s) under Rule 187(2) present for the final vote	Sergio Gaetano Cofferati, Olle Schmidt

OPINION of the Committee on Women’s Rights and Gender Equality (19.7.2011)

for the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs

on the Agenda for New Skills and Jobs
(2011/2067(INI))

Rapporteur: Joanna Katarzyna Skrzydlewska

SUGGESTIONS

The Committee on Women’s Rights and Gender Equality calls on the Committee on Employment and Social Affairs, as the committee responsible, to incorporate the following suggestions in its motion for a resolution:

A. whereas one of the aims of the Europe 2020 Strategy is to increase the level of employment of men and women in the EU to 75 %, and whereas the employment rate for women in the EU is currently at the level of 58.2 %, with vast discrepancies among Member States,

B.  whereas the EU 2020 Strategy puts an emphasis on ecological transformation, the renewable sector and science- and technology-intensive green jobs for a sustainable economy, and whereas women remain under-represented both in courses and in related jobs, leading to severe gender segregation by sector,

C. whereas, even though microcredit is a vital tool for female entrepreneurship and the creation of family businesses, women remain underrepresented in business in the European Union, representing an average of 30% of all entrepreneurs,

D. whereas over 60 % of students graduating from universities are women, whereas not enough women and girls go into science, leading to severe gender segregation by sector, and whereas the gender gap between women and men’s employment in the IT sector has tended to widen rather than narrow over time,

E.  whereas gender gaps in the EU labour markets persist in pay, in part-time versus full-time rates and in employment rates, due inter alia to parenthood, and whereas labour market segregation in employment is a major obstacle to a properly functioning EU labour market,

1.  Highlights the fact that, in order to raise the employment level of women, Member States must pay special attention to efficient implementation of anti-discrimination legislation and family-friendly provisions, promote recruitment to non-traditional jobs through voluntary measures and attainable targets, and provide for accessibility and accountability; emphasises the importance of monitoring the labour market and skills requirements; invites the Member States to offer comprehensive support to national labour and education ministries in order to implement gender mainstreaming programmes;

2.  Stresses that, in order to have highly qualified and skilled women workers on the labour market, it is necessary to empower women to enter, re-enter and advance in the labour market, particularly the vulnerable ones who face structural unemployment and difficulties with returning to work, either due to jobs lost because of the recent financial crisis, or after maternity or parental leave, or for other reasons, with retraining opportunities and access to vocational training, regardless of the type of work contract, with the aim of improving their qualifications; stresses, furthermore, that it is necessary to provide women with access and incentives to active participation in life-long learning at every stage of their careers, and to promote technical and engineering studies among girls with a view to flexible adaptation of education and training to the needs of the labour market, particularly the need for highly skilled workers;

3.  Underlines the need for investment in effective educational and vocational guidance systems in order to guide young women towards choosing science, engineering or technical higher education, be it academic or non-academic; notes that particular attention must be paid to integrating ICT competences, digital literacy and communication skills into the vocational training and life-long learning policies of the Member States and to encouraging women to take advantage of them, and to broadening training opportunities for women so as to enable them to adapt to changes in the labour market during their careers, thus increasing their presence in strategic sectors for future development; considers it necessary to fight gender stereotypes in education;

4.  Maintains that, if the qualifications and skills of female workers are to be preserved in a changing economic space and those who so wish are to be helped to return to work, it is essential that workers on parental leave should also be included in the training activities organised by their employer;

5.  Calls on the Member States to increase their efforts to prevent segregation of job markets by including in their structural labour market reforms instruments such as the European Social Fund (ESF) to combat professional segregation of women, as manifested both in the inadequate representation of women in leading positions and in the gender-segregated labour market, through effective measures against prejudices and stereotypes, as well as ‘glass ceiling’ barriers, exchange of good practice and benchmarking indicators between the Member States, and legislative measures including quotas to increase women’s representation in leading positions;

6.  Calls on the Commission and the Member States to support measures for reconciliation of professional and family life, and to invest in women’s labour market participation through promotion of diversity management, professional encouragement of women and promotion of the creation of new posts with more flexible forms of working conditions;

7.  Stresses that new jobs should be accompanied by new forms of working arrangements that will enable workers with dependent children to work alternative hours, reduce their working time or opt for teleworking;

8.  Encourages the Commission to promote gender mainstreaming in industry to enable equal participation of men and women, with specific attention being dedicated to traditionally male-dominated sectors;

9.  Calls on the Commission to complement the existing legal framework on work-life balance and to put forward new legislative proposals covering paternity leave, adoption leave and care leave for dependants; notes with concern the current deadlock in the Council with regard to the proposed revision of Directive 92/85/EEC;

10. Highlights the need to arrange the labour market in the interest of reconciling work and family life by setting up structures and institutions for the care of children, older people and other dependants to meet real needs and to ensure high-quality accessible care services for all, so as to enable working mothers to achieve work-life balance in order to improve labour market participation and the economic independence of women;

11. Highlights the need to introduce more flexible working times and various options for tele-working without jeopardising the economic independence of employees, especially women, who are more often employed temporarily and part-time non-voluntarily; stresses the need for decent wages and access to social security, whether working full-time or part-time;

12. Notes that opportunities to raise the rate of women’s employment are offered not only by the ‘white-job’ sector but also by the home defence sector, the logistics sector (including transport), the business services sector – insurance and consulting, for example – and the ecological sector and sustainable jobs;

13. Urges the Commission and Member States to support and develop specific programmes geared to recruiting women to technical professions through subsidies for young female academics, in line with best practice in certain Member States such as the ‘Excellentia’ programme in Austria, which has made it possible to double the number of female S&T university professors and has contributed to the establishment of high-quality research centres led by women;

14. Underlines that ‘green jobs’ have the potential to become a key growth segment of the future European labour market; calls on the Council, Commission and Member States to ensure that women benefit from these jobs to the same extent as men; calls for special attention in order to ensure that the transformation to renewable energy and investment in green technologies to modernise the physical infrastructure also entails a development towards decent, high-quality work for men and women;

15. Calls on the Commission and the Member States to encourage the private and public sector to take all possible and necessary action to eliminate the gender pay gap and the major inequalities in terms of access, pay, career development, participation and governance, with the aim of improving women’s participation in the labour market; stresses, in this connection, the importance of transparency in the form of better statistics, and of a usable definition of ‘work of equal value’; welcomes the Commission’s announcements on reviewing the pension system for those with gaps in pension-saving contributions due to periods of unemployment, sickness or caring duties, which concern mainly women;

RESULT OF FINAL VOTE IN COMMITTEE

Date adopted	13.7.2011
Result of final vote	+: –: 0:	26 2 2
Members present for the final vote	Regina Bastos, Edit Bauer, Marije Cornelissen, Silvia Costa, Edite Estrela, Ilda Figueiredo, Zita Gurmai, Teresa Jiménez-Becerril Barrio, Nicole Kiil-Nielsen, Astrid Lulling, Barbara Matera, Angelika Niebler, Siiri Oviir, Antonyia Parvanova, Joanna Katarzyna Skrzydlewska, Eva-Britt Svensson, Britta Thomsen, Marina Yannakoudakis, Anna Záborská
Substitute(s) present for the final vote	Izaskun Bilbao Barandica, Vilija Blinkevičiūtė, Christa Klaß, Mojca Kleva, Mariya Nedelcheva, Norica Nicolai, Chrysoula Paliadeli, Antigoni Papadopoulou, Sirpa Pietikäinen, Angelika Werthmann
Substitute(s) under Rule 187(2) present for the final vote	Jacek Włosowicz

RESULT OF FINAL VOTE IN COMMITTEE

Date adopted	26.9.2011
Result of final vote	+: –: 0:	30 3 14
Members present for the final vote	Regina Bastos, Edit Bauer, Jean-Luc Bennahmias, Pervenche Berès, Mara Bizzotto, Philippe Boulland, Milan Cabrnoch, David Casa, Alejandro Cercas, Ole Christensen, Derek Roland Clark, Sergio Gaetano Cofferati, Tadeusz Cymański, Frédéric Daerden, Proinsias De Rossa, Frank Engel, Sari Essayah, Richard Falbr, Ilda Figueiredo, Marian Harkin, Roger Helmer, Nadja Hirsch, Liisa Jaakonsaari, Danuta Jazłowiecka, Martin Kastler, Ádám Kósa, Patrick Le Hyaric, Veronica Lope Fontagné, Thomas Mann, Elisabeth Morin-Chartier, Csaba Őry, Siiri Oviir, Rovana Plumb, Sylvana Rapti, Licia Ronzulli, Elisabeth Schroedter, Joanna Katarzyna Skrzydlewska, Jutta Steinruck, Traian Ungureanu
Substitute(s) present for the final vote	Raffaele Baldassarre, Jelko Kacin, Ria Oomen-Ruijten, Antigoni Papadopoulou, Evelyn Regner, Emilie Turunen, Cecilia Wikström, Tatjana Ždanoka