Procedure : 2017/2186(DEC)
Document stages in plenary
Document selected : A8-0076/2018

Texts tabled :

A8-0076/2018

Debates :

PV 18/04/2018 - 10
CRE 18/04/2018 - 10

Votes :

PV 18/04/2018 - 12.68
CRE 18/04/2018 - 12.68

Texts adopted :

P8_TA(2018)0173

REPORT     
PDF 317kWORD 62k
22.3.2018
PE 613.434v02-00 A8-0076/2018

on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016

(2017/2186(DEC))

Committee on Budgetary Control

Rapporteur: Brian Hayes

1. PROPOSAL FOR A EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT DECISION

1. PROPOSAL FOR A EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT DECISION

on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016

(2017/2186(DEC))

The European Parliament,

–  having regard to the final annual accounts of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016,

–  having regard to the Court of Auditors’ report on the annual accounts of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016, together with the Joint Undertaking’s reply(1),

–  having regard to the statement of assurance(2) as to the reliability of the accounts and the legality and regularity of the underlying transactions provided by the Court of Auditors for the financial year 2016, pursuant to Article 287 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,

–  having regard to the Council’s recommendation of 20 February 2018 on discharge to be given to the joint undertaking in respect of the implementation of the budget for the financial year 2016 (05943/2018 – C8‑0095/2018),

–  having regard to Article 319 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,

–  having regard to Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2012 on the financial rules applicable to the general budget of the Union and repealing Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No 1605/2002(3), and in particular Article 209 thereof,

–  having regard to Council Regulation (EC) No 642/2014 of 16 June 2014 establishing the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking(4), and in particular Article 12 thereof,

–  having regard to Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 110/2014 of 30 September 2013 on the model financial regulation for public-private partnership bodies referred to in Article 209 of Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council(5),

–  having regard to Rule 94 of and Annex IV to its Rules of Procedure,

–  having regard to the report of the Committee on Budgetary Control and the opinion of the Committee on Transport and Tourism (A8-0076/2018),

1.  Grants the Executive Director of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking discharge in respect of the implementation of the Joint Undertaking’s budget for the financial year 2016;

2.  Sets out its observations in the resolution below;

3.  Instructs its President to forward this decision and the resolution forming an integral part of it to the Executive Director of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking, the Council, the Commission and the Court of Auditors, and to arrange for their publication in the Official Journal of the European Union (L series).

2. PROPOSAL FOR A EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT DECISION

on the closure of the accounts of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016

(2017/2186(DEC))

The European Parliament,

–  having regard to the final annual accounts of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016,

–  having regard to the Court of Auditors’ report on the annual accounts of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016, together with the Joint Undertaking’s reply(6),

–  having regard to the statement of assurance(7) as to the reliability of the accounts and the legality and regularity of the underlying transactions provided by the Court of Auditors for the financial year 2016, pursuant to Article 287 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,

–  having regard to the Council’s recommendation of 20 February 2018 on discharge to be given to the joint undertaking in respect of the implementation of the budget for the financial year 2016 (05943/2018 – C8‑0095/2018),

–  having regard to Article 319 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,

–  having regard to Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2012 on the financial rules applicable to the general budget of the Union and repealing Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No 1605/2002(8), and in particular Article 209 thereof,

–  having regard to Council Regulation (EC) No 642/2014 of 16 June 2014 establishing the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking(9), and in particular Article 12 thereof,

–  having regard to Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 110/2014 of 30 September 2013 on the model financial regulation for public-private partnership bodies referred to in Article 209 of Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council(10),

–  having regard to Rule 94 of and Annex IV to its Rules of Procedure,

–  having regard to the report of the Committee on Budgetary Control and the opinion of the Committee on Transport and Tourism (A8-0076/2018),

1.  Approves the closure of the accounts of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016;

2.  Instructs its President to forward this decision to the Executive Director of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking, the Council, the Commission and the Court of Auditors, and to arrange for its publication in the Official Journal of the European Union (L series).

3. MOTION FOR A EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT RESOLUTION

with observations forming an integral part of the decision on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget for the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016

(2017/2186(DEC))

The European Parliament,

–  having regard to its decision on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016,

–  having regard to Rule 94 of and Annex IV to its Rules of Procedure,

–  having regard to the report of the Committee on Budgetary Control and the opinion of the Committee on Transport and Tourism (A8-0076/2018),

A.  whereas the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking (the “Joint Undertaking”) was established in June 2014 for a period of 10 years by Council Regulation 642/2014 (the “Regulation establishing the Joint Undertaking”);

B.  whereas the founding members are the European Union, represented by the Commission, and rail industry partners (key stakeholders, including rail equipment manufacturers, railway companies, infrastructure managers and research centres); with the possibility that other entities may participate in the Joint Undertaking as associated members;

C.  whereas the objectives of the Joint Undertaking are: (a) to achieve a Single European Railway Area; (b) to enhance the attractiveness and competitiveness of the European railway system; (c) to ensure a modal shift from road transport; and (d) to maintain the European rail industry’s leading position in the global market;

D.  whereas the Joint Undertaking started to work autonomously in May 2016;

General

1.  Acknowledges that the Court of Auditors’ report on the annual accounts of the Joint Undertaking for the year ended 31 December 2016 (the “Court’s report”) presents fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of the Joint Undertaking at 31 December 2016, the results of its operations, its cash flows, and the changes in net assets for the year then ended, in accordance with its Financial Regulation and with accounting rules adopted by the Commission’s accounting officer;

2.  Acknowledges that the Court´s report states that the transactions underlying the annual accounts of the Joint Undertaking for the financial year 2016 are, in all material respects, legal and regular;

3.  Notes that the maximum Union contribution to the activities of the Joint Undertaking is EUR 450 000 000, to be paid from Horizon 2020; notes that the industry members of the Joint Undertaking are to contribute resources of at least EUR 470 000 000, consisting of at least EUR 350 000 000 for in-kind and cash contributions to the operational activities and administrative costs of the Joint Undertaking and at least EUR 120 000 000 of in-kind contributions to the Joint Undertaking’s additional activities;

Budget and financial management

4.  Notes that the final 2016 budget available for implementation included commitment appropriations of EUR 50 200 000 and payment appropriations of EUR 52 300 000; stresses that the utilisation rates for commitment and payment appropriations were 94 % and 82 % respectively which represent a low level especially for payment appropriations; notes moreover that most of the payments made by the Joint Undertaking in 2016 were pre-financing payments for Horizon 2020 projects selected under the 2015 and 2016 calls for proposals;

5.  Notes that out of the EUR 450 000 000 of Horizon 2020 funds assigned to the Shift2Rail initiative, EUR 52 000 000 were earmarked for the Horizon 2020 Transport Work Programme 2014-2015 managed by the Commission, resulting in EUR 398 000 000 allocated to the Joint Undertaking; observes that by the end of 2016, the Joint Undertaking had made commitments of EUR 92 400 000 and payments of EUR 42 700 000 (10,7 % of the allocated funds) for the implementation of its first wave of projects;

6.  Acknowledges the fact that out of the EUR 350 000 000 of contributions to be made by the industry members to the operational activities and administrative costs of the Joint Undertaking, by the end of 2016, i.e. four months after the Joint Undertaking had launched its first Horizon 2020 projects, the members had reported in-kind contributions of EUR 4 500 000 for operational activities, of which EUR 3 000 000 had been certified; notes that the Governing Board had validated cash contributions to the Joint Undertaking’s administrative costs of EUR 3 200 000;

7.  Takes note that out of the EUR 120 000 000 of industry members’ contributions to be made to additional activities, by the end of 2016 the members had already reported EUR 55 000 000 (45.8 %), of which EUR 35 200 000 had been certified;

8.  Observes that by the end of 2016, the total contributions from industry members amounted to EUR 62 700 000, compared to the Union’s cash contribution of EUR 48 500 000;

9.  Notes that, in 2016, the Joint Undertaking signed 27 grant agreements resulting from the calls of 2015 and 2016, and that the value of the research and innovation activities of those calls amounted to EUR 167,3 million, to be co-funded by the Joint Undertaking up to a maximum of EUR 79,1 million;

Prevention and management of conflicts of interest and transparency

10.  Notes that even though the Commission's research anti-fraud strategy is mandatory for the Joint Undertaking, at the end of 2016, the Joint Undertaking had not yet performed a specific anti-fraud risk assessment, nor had it established an action plan for the implementation of its own anti-fraud strategy, both important and expected systems of governance and best practice based on the methodology provided by the Commission; notes the fact that in 2017 the Joint Undertaking took the first steps towards establishing its own anti-fraud action plan, i.e. an anti-fraud awareness session for Joint Undertaking staff organised by OLAF, and an anti-fraud risk assessment; notes that this plan will be followed by an impact assessment establishing the key objectives relating to mitigation of identifiable weaknesses (Q4 2017) and an evaluation of the anti-fraud strategy and the action plan by June 2018;

Personal selection and recruitment

11.  Notes that in 2016, the Joint Undertaking recruited 7 members of staff in accordance with its Staff Establishment Plan: an executive director, a head of administration and finance, a communication officer, an IT assistant and three programme managers;

12.  Notes that at the end of 2016, the Joint Undertaking’s staff consisted of 17 members as foreseen in the establishment plan;

Internal Control

13.  Notes that, according to the Court´s report, the Joint Undertaking has set up an action plan for the implementation of its internal control framework, which takes into account the results of a risk assessment completed by the Commission’s Internal Audit Service (IAS) in December 2016; notes moreover that ex-post audits of project cost claims by independent external auditors are to be launched after the validation of the first cost claims in the course of 2017;

14.  Acknowledges the fact that IAS performs the role of Internal Auditor of the Joint Undertaking and, in this respect, it reports to the Governing Board and the Executive Director indirectly; notes that the first audit mission consisted in establishing a risk profile of the Joint Undertaking with the objective of establishing a triennial internal audit work plan;

Operational procurement and grants

15.  Expresses its concern that in its procedures for the procurement of services, the Joint Undertaking unwisely set a maximum contract budget; observes that there was no evidence that this maximum amount has been based on a cost estimation process and a reasonable market price reference system; takes the view that this might not ensure the cost-effectiveness of its multi-annual service contracts, as experience shows that most of the bids received were close to the maximum budget; welcomes the fact that the approach followed by the Joint Undertaking is in line with the provisions of the Commission Procurement Vademecum and the principles of its Financial Regulation;

16.  Draws attention to the fact that in two cases out of eight, the Joint Undertaking awarded grants to project consortia, despite the fact that the checks of the financial viability of the beneficiaries performed by the Research Executive Agency indicated that the financial capacity of the coordinating industry members of the consortia was weak; notes that this implies an unnecessarily high financial risk for the completion of those projects and the financial risk was particularly high in one case, in which the coordinating partner had been assigned over 45% of the total project funding; calls on the Joint Undertaking to provide before the end of 2018 the clear reasons why it decided to take such risk and to inform in written the discharge authority about the development of both projects as a part of the discharge follow up; draws attention to the ongoing and substantial need for a proper risk assessment system that should be followed in a comprehensive fashion;

Others issues

17.  Calls on the Commission to ensure the direct involvement of the Joint Undertaking in the process of the Horizon 2020 mid-term review in the sphere of further simplifications and harmonisation of joint undertakings;

18.  Recognises the need for the Joint Undertaking to communicate with Union citizens, through the Union institutions, concerning the significant research and collaboration that it is undertaking, stresses the importance of highlighting the real improvements achieved as a consequence of its work, which are an important part of its mandate, as well as the fact that it works with other joint undertakings in promoting public awareness of the benefits of their work. Notes in this respect that also many of the private partners of the Joint Undertaking are endowed with capacities to communicate directly with Union citizens and should be encouraged to participate in such an effort.

19.  Underlines the fact that research and innovation in the rail sector are decisive for the development of a safe and globally competitive rail sector and play an important role in order to achieve a significant reduction of the life-cycle cost of the railway transport system and to achieve significant increases in capacity of the railway transport system, in reliability and punctuality, as well as in order to remove the remaining technical obstacles to interoperability and to reduce the negative externalities linked to transport; highlights also that the objectives of the Joint Undertaking are to achieve a Single European Railway Area and to enhance the attractiveness and competitiveness of the European railway system;

20.  Recalls that research and innovation is not an isolated process using a simple rule for process management; stresses therefore that it is significantly important to identify among the research and innovation projects those that are capable to bring innovative solutions to the market; highlights that changes in the Regulation establishing the Joint Undertaking and in its Statutes will be very important for the future development of the Joint Undertaking in order to improve its efficiency; stresses, in particular that there is a need to foresee the use of the principle of multiannual financing and to adopt flexible timetables for publishing projects proposals;

21.  Insists on the importance of the cooperation between the Joint Undertaking and the Union Agency for Railways (ERA); welcomes the involvement of ERA in meetings of the Joint Undertaking governing board; asks the Joint Undertaking to provide more concrete information on the main achievements of this cooperation in its annual activity report;

22.  Takes note of the fact that, during the first months since it became autonomous, the Joint Undertaking started some exploratory work to consider how to make use of activities planned in other Union programmes and funds, in relation to the railway sector, in particular EFSI, Regional and Cohesion fund, and that the Joint Undertaking intends to further develop this activity; requests the Joint Unertaking to provide details about how it intends to develop synergies between those activities and what are the expected outcomes;

23.  Underlines that research and innovation projects should be followed by a higher Technology Readiness Level (TRL) in the demonstration and implementation phase; stresses that the necessity of complementary financing using the relevant funding instruments is key to build a competitive railway system in the future.

21.2.2018

OPINION of the Committee on Transport and Tourism

for the Committee on Budgetary Control

on discharge in respect of the implementation of the budget of the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking (S2R JU) for the financial year 2016

(2017/2186(DEC))

Rapporteur: Markus Ferber

SUGGESTIONS

The Committee on Transport and Tourism calls on the Committee on Budgetary Control, as the committee responsible, to incorporate the following suggestions into its motion for a resolution:

1.  Welcomes the fact that the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking (‘S2R JU’) achieved its financial autonomy in May 2016 and has proceeded with the consolidation of its structure in order to ensure sound management, legality and regularity in Programme execution;

2.  Welcomes the finding of the Court of Auditors that the transactions underlying the accounts of the S2R JU for the financial year 2016 are legal and regular in all material respects;

3.  Notes that the S2R JU annual budget for 2016 was EUR 50,2 million in commitment appropriations and EUR 52,3 million in payment appropriations, of which EUR 44,1 million was in commitment and 47,2 million in payment for operational expenditure, EUR 3,3 million in commitment and EUR 3,5 million in payment for staff and administrative expenditure and EUR 2,8 million in commitment and EUR 1,7 million in payment for unused appropriations not required in the financial year;

4.  Notes that, in 2016, the operational costs (Title 3) represented 87,8 % of the overall S2R JU budget, including the expected un-used appropriations not required in the year (Title 4); further notes that, for the operational budget, the S2R JU attained a rate of implementation of 100 % for the commitment appropriations and a rate of payment appropriations of 86,6 %; notes that the payment appropriations were used for the pre-financing of the grants resulting from the 2015 and 2016 calls for proposals;

5.  Regrets that in 2016 the income appropriations from the nineteen associated members (‘Other Members’) amounted only to EUR 2,53 million out of a total of EUR 52,32 million; further regrets that estimated in-kind contributions from Other Members other than the Union to operational activities were limited to EUR 4,5 million, of which EUR 3 million had been certified; recalls that the S2R JU Regulation(11) establishes that the total contribution to operational activities that is to be provided by the Other Members, totalling EUR 470 million, shall consist of at least EUR 350 million of in-kind and cash contributions, including EUR 200 million from founding members other than the Union; notes that, out of the EUR 120 million of industry members’ contributions to be made to additional activities, members reported EUR 55 million (45,8 %) by the end of 2016, of which EUR 35,2 million had been certified;

6.  Notes that, in 2016, the S2R JU signed 27 grant agreements resulting from the calls of 2015 and 2016, and that the value of the R&I activities of those calls amounted to EUR 167,3 million, to be co-funded by S2R JU up to a maximum of EUR 79,1 million;

7.  Notes that the S2R JU has set up a risk management policy but has not yet performed a specific anti-fraud assessment, nor has it established an action plan for the implementation of its own anti-fraud strategy; notes also that, since only pre-financing of projects has been paid in 2016, no ex-post controls have been carried out; encourages the S2R JU to adopt, as soon as possible, an ex-post control strategy; asks the S2R JU to provide details on the risk management system, and in particular on how to avoid conflicts of interest;

8.  Is concerned that in its procedure for the procurement services, S2R JU sets a maximum contract budget, which does not seem to be based on a cost estimation process and a reasonable market price reference system; asks the S2R JU to put in place appropriate cost estimation processes before launching procurement procedures in order to ensure the cost-effectiveness of its multi-annual service contracts, as experience shows that most of the bids received were close to the maximum budget;

9.  Notes that 17 statutory staff posts had been filled by 31 December 2016; regrets that the S2R JU had to have recourse to external support to fill staffing gaps during the recruitment process to cope with the workload, and that payments for these external services were not made in 2016; asks the S2R JU to provide information on these expenses;

10.  Underlines the fact that research and innovation in the rail sector are decisive for the development of a safe and globally competitive rail sector and play an important role in order to achieve a significant reduction of the life-cycle cost of the railway transport system and to achieve significant increases in capacity of the railway transport system, in reliability and punctuality, as well as in order to remove the remaining technical obstacles to interoperability and to reduce the negative externalities linked to transport; highlights also that the objectives of the S2R JU are to achieve a Single European Railway Area and to enhance the attractiveness and competitiveness of the European railway system;

11.  Recalls that research and innovation is not an isolated process using a simple rule for process management; stresses therefore that it is significantly important to identify among the research and innovation projects those that are capable to bring innovative solutions to the market; highlights that changes in the Regulation establishing the S2R JU and in its Statutes will be very important for the next S2R JU development in order to improve its efficiency; stresses, in particular that there is a need to foresee the use of the principle of multiannual financing and to adopt flexible timetables for publishing projects proposals;

12.  Insists on the importance of the cooperation between the S2R JU and the Union Agency for Railways (ERA); welcomes the involvement of ERA in meetings of the JU governing board; asks the S2R JU to provide more concrete information on the main achievements of this cooperation in its annual activity report;

13.  Takes note of the fact that, during the first months since it became autonomous, the S2R JU started some exploratory work to consider how to make use of activities planned in other Union programmes and funds, in relation to the railway sector, in particular EFSI, Regional and Cohesion fund, and that the S2R JU intends to further develop this activity; requests the S2R JU to provide details about how it intends to develop synergies between those activities and what are the expected outcomes;

14.  Underlines that research and innovation projects should be followed by a higher Technology Readiness Level (TRL) in the demonstration and implementation phase; stresses that the necessity of complementary financing using the relevant funding instruments is key to build a competitive railway system in the future;

15.  Proposes that Parliament grants discharge to the Executive Director of the Joint Undertaking in respect of the implementation of the S2R JU’s budget for the financial year 2016.

INFORMATION ON ADOPTION IN COMMITTEE ASKED FOR OPINION

Date adopted

20.2.2018

 

 

 

Result of final vote

+:

–:

0:

39

3

0

Members present for the final vote

Daniela Aiuto, Lucy Anderson, Marie-Christine Arnautu, Georges Bach, Izaskun Bilbao Barandica, Deirdre Clune, Michael Cramer, Luis de Grandes Pascual, Andor Deli, Isabella De Monte, Ismail Ertug, Jacqueline Foster, Dieter-Lebrecht Koch, Miltiadis Kyrkos, Bogusław Liberadzki, Marian-Jean Marinescu, Renaud Muselier, Markus Pieper, Tomasz Piotr Poręba, Gabriele Preuß, Christine Revault d’Allonnes Bonnefoy, Dominique Riquet, Massimiliano Salini, Claudia Schmidt, Jill Seymour, Keith Taylor, Pavel Telička, István Ujhelyi, Wim van de Camp, Marie-Pierre Vieu, Janusz Zemke, Roberts Zīle, Elżbieta Katarzyna Łukacijewska

Substitutes present for the final vote

Jakop Dalunde, Michael Detjen, Markus Ferber, Maria Grapini, Rolandas Paksas, Jozo Radoš, Evžen Tošenovský, Henna Virkkunen

Substitutes under Rule 200(2) present for the final vote

Olle Ludvigsson

FINAL VOTE BY ROLL CALL IN COMMITTEE ASKED FOR OPINION

39

+

ALDE

Izaskun Bilbao Barandica, Jozo Radoš, Dominique Riquet, Pavel Telička

ECR

Tomasz Piotr Poręba, Evžen Tošenovský, Roberts Zīle

EFDD

Daniela Aiuto, Rolandas Paksas

GUE/NGL

Marie-Pierre Vieu

PPE

Georges Bach, Deirdre Clune, Andor Deli, Markus Ferber, Dieter-Lebrecht Koch, Elżbieta Katarzyna Łukacijewska, Marian-Jean Marinescu, Renaud Muselier, Markus Pieper, Massimiliano Salini, Claudia Schmidt, Henna Virkkunen, Luis de Grandes Pascual, Wim van de Camp

S&D

Lucy Anderson, Isabella De Monte, Michael Detjen, Ismail Ertug, Maria Grapini, Miltiadis Kyrkos, Bogusław Liberadzki, Olle Ludvigsson, Gabriele Preuß, Christine Revault d'Allonnes Bonnefoy, István Ujhelyi, Janusz Zemke

Verts/ALE

Michael Cramer, Jakop Dalunde, Keith Taylor

3

-

ECR

Jacqueline Foster

EFDD

Jill Seymour

ENF

Marie-Christine Arnautu

0

0

 

 

Key to symbols:

+  :  in favour

-  :  against

0  :  abstention

INFORMATION ON ADOPTION IN COMMITTEE RESPONSIBLE

Date adopted

20.3.2018

 

 

 

Result of final vote

+:

–:

0:

18

6

0

Members present for the final vote

Nedzhmi Ali, Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, Dennis de Jong, Tamás Deutsch, Martina Dlabajová, Raffaele Fitto, Ingeborg Gräßle, Cătălin Sorin Ivan, Jean-François Jalkh, Arndt Kohn, Notis Marias, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Bart Staes, Indrek Tarand, Marco Valli, Derek Vaughan, Tomáš Zdechovský, Joachim Zeller

Substitutes present for the final vote

Karin Kadenbach, Julia Pitera, Miroslav Poche

FINAL VOTE BY ROLL CALL IN COMMITTEE RESPONSIBLE

18

+

ALDE

Nedzhmi Ali, Martina Dlabajová

GUE/NGL

Dennis de Jong

PPE

Tamás Deutsch, Ingeborg Gräßle, Julia Pitera, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Petri Sarvamaa, Claudia Schmidt, Tomáš Zdechovský, Joachim Zeller

S&D

Inés Ayala Sender, Zigmantas Balčytis, Cătălin Sorin Ivan, Karin Kadenbach, Arndt Kohn, Miroslav Poche, Derek Vaughan

6

-

ECR

Raffaele Fitto, Notis Marias

EFDD

Marco Valli

ENF

Jean-François Jalkh

VERTS/ALE

Bart Staes, Indrek Tarand

0

0

 

 

Key to symbols:

+  :  in favour

-  :  against

0  :  abstention

(1)

OJ C 426, 12.12.2017, p. 64.

(2)

OJ C 426, 12.12.2017, p. 64.

(3)

OJ L 298, 26.10.2012, p. 1.

(4)

OJ L 177, 17.6.2014, p. 9.

(5)

OJ L 38, 7.2.2014, p. 2.

(6)

OJ C 426, 12.12.2017, p. 64.

(7)

OJ C 426, 12.12.2017, p. 64.

(8)

OJ L 298, 26.10.2012, p. 1.

(9)

OJ L 177, 17.6.2014, p. 9.

(10)

OJ L 38, 7.2.2014, p. 2.

(11)

  Council Regulation (EU) No 642/2014 of 16 June 2014 establishing the Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking, OJ L 177, 17.6.2014, p. 9.

Last updated: 27 March 2018Legal notice - Privacy policy