| Home |



Official positions of the other Institutions and Organs - Council of the Union


Reflection Group's Report

Messina 2nd June 1995

Brussels 5th December 1995


SECOND PART: AN ANNOTATED AGENDA

I. REFORM OF THE EUROPEAN UNION: A COMMITMENT TO THE FUTURE

A. WHY REFORM?: MANDATE AND CHALLENGES

1. In addition to the mandate contained in the Treaty on European Union (TEU) and the commitments subsequently entered into by the Council and the European Councils, all of which were aimed either at completing the work of Maastricht or at dealing with specific institutional issues raised as a result of the most recent enlargement or preparing adequately for the next one, there are further substantive reasons for holding the 1996 Intergovernmental Conference (IGC 96).

The Group has identified two fundamental reasons, namely improving the functioning of the Union on the one hand, and, on the other, creating the conditions to enable it to cope successfully with the internal and external challenges facing it, and notably the next enlargement.

The mandate of the Conference

2. The mandate of the 1996 Conference, the legal basis for which is Article N of the TEU, was in part set by the Treaty itself and its accompanying Declarations. Hence:

3. In the framework of the negotiations for the accession of Austria, Finland, Norway and Sweden, various institutional issues arose which were dealt with at the Brussels European Council, in the "Ioannina compromise" and at the Corfu European Council. All those issues (reform of the institutions in general, including the weighting of votes and the number of votes for a qualified majority in the Council, the number of members of the Commission and "any other measures necessary to facilitate the work of the institutions in a spirit of democracy and openness and guarantee their effective operation with a view to enlargement") will also have to be dealt with at the IGC 96.

As a result of inter-institutional agreements between the European Parliament, the Council and the Commission, questions relating to budgetary discipline and procedure and the implementation of Community acts (committee procedure) have been added to the Conference agenda.

4. It goes without saying that this planned agenda is likely to be supplemented, in accordance with Article N, by other topics raised by the member States or the institutions. Notwithstanding that possibility, in the light of the experience acquired after the entry into force of the Treaty on European Union, and taking into account the challenges and difficulties posed in particular by the prospect of further enlargement, the Cannes European Council felt that the discussion in the Reflection Group should focus on a number of priorities to enable the Union to respond to its citizens' expectations. These priorities are:

The new challenges facing Europe

Internal challenges

5. A key challenge facing the Union internally is the need to ensure that European construction becomes a venture to which citizens can relate.

Most Europeans consider that community integration is an invaluable asset, assuring peace in an increasingly unstable continent and prosperity in a global market. Nevertheless, the growing popular dissatisfaction with public matters in general affects also the European construction, partly due to economic, social, political and institutional reasons: a high level of unemployment, which is particularly serious in the case of young people and the long-term unemployed; environmental degradation; social rejection and exclusion; major changes in our demographic structures, which undermine the European social model; the crisis in the political contract between representatives and those represented; the European Union's growing complexity and the lack of information on, and understanding of, its raison d'être; finally, the worrying phenomenon of organized crime (drug trafficking, money laundering, terrorism).

As a result, there is a growing call for public security that cannot be met by States acting alone, and that is not receiving a satisfactory response from the Union. This is due to the gaps or shortcomings in the Union's mechanisms and to the lack of political will to remedy these.

External challenges

6. Other major challenges are a result of the profound changes taking place outside the Union as the end of the century approaches.

The magnitude of some of the challenges which can only be met by adopting an equally broad, global approach is demonstrated by questions such as major political instability in the European region following the end of the cold war, despite greater overall security; strong migratory pressures which are particularly acute in Europe; risks of ecological imbalances which the Union and the member States cannot afford to ignore, etc., and an increasing globalization of the economy which highlights Europe's loss of some of the comparative advantages gained through its social and technological innovations.

The challenge of enlargement

7. The next enlargement represents both a politicalimperativeandanewopportunity for Europe, but at the same time it presents the Union with a major challenge requiring an adequate response:

The next enlargement will be a great opportunity for Europe and will also be different from the previous ones because of the large number of applicant countries and the heterogeneity of their political, economic and social situations. To ensure that the next enlargement does not weaken, change the nature of or actually break up the Union, the reforms needed to cope with the challenges involved must first be made. The enlargement negotiations cannot begin until the 1996 Conference has been concluded satisfactorily. The success of the former thus depends on the success of the latter.

The responses

8. As we have just seen, the new situation inside and outside Europe raises questions and requires the European Union and the Member States to provide responses which will ensure greater political stability while simultaneously allowing economic development and the proper social climate to be maintained within an open, global and competitive economy. In other words, responses which will enable the European Union to continue acting as a crucial factor for peace and prosperity on our continent.

Some of Europe's responses to these challenges have already been identified, as in the case of Economic and Monetary Union, achievement of which is a priority for Europe, as agreed in the Maastricht Treaty and ratified by the national parliaments. The Group strongly feels that the EMU should carry on its process of implementation in accordance with what was agreed.

9. The next enlargement also constitutes a response to the challenges of security and political and economic stability in Europe. However,in order to achieve it, reforms of the Union are required insomeareasand, very significantly, in the Union's institutions. Other possible responses have already been formulated, as stated in the introduction, by the Treaty itself or by subsequent European Councils. It is the Reflection Group, however, that has been given the task of identifying and producing concrete proposals. The Group shares the points which follow.

10. As stated above, the Union's principal internal challenge is to reconcile itself with its citizens. Therefore, enhancing its legitimacy in their eyes has to be the prime task of the coming reform.

The achievement of this aim will depend on a clear definition of the Union's objectives, i.e. the joint goals sought, the credibility of common policies and the cooperation machinery designed to attain those objectives (or, to put it another way, the suitability of the instruments for the purpose of achieving the objectives set) and the preservation of the Union's internal cohesion.

Those principles should be put into practice through concrete measures, such as improved application of the subsidiarity principle ("who does what?"); Community legislation concentrating on essentials; promotion of competitiveness on a European scale; simplification (of texts and procedures); effective enforcement of the rights of the Union's citizens; promotion of equality between men and women; greater political responsibility for the Institutions combined with increased accountability on their part; the fight against fraud; greater transparency in the functioning of the Institutions, which should be given the means to take decisions with the broadest possible backing from citizens; and closer involvement of national parliaments in the Union's tasks.

11. On the other hand, the responses to the challenges posed by the profound changes which have taken place outside the Union, in the political and security context as well as in the economic and commercial sphere, need to be based on reinforcement of the instruments set up to achieve the highest possible levels of external stability and security.

B. PRINCIPLES AND OBJECTIVES

The objective to be achieved

12. A prime objective to be achieved can be established from a mere enumeration of the challenges and the responses to them: maintenance of strong European integration and cooperation in this new end-of-the-century context, as, together with the organizations responsible for European security and national policies, they are both a guarantee of peace and prosperity for the citizens of the Union.

The Group emphasizes that this guarantee of prosperity and peace is not perpetual and that it would be a grave error to underestimate the Community's main contribution to the Member States and their citizens, namely a shared view of life that has ruled out war as a means of settling differences and has decided to follow resolutely the path of growth respecting the environment, competitiveness and employment, promoting stringency in public finances and in combating inflation as the best way to meet citizens' demands. The Group accordingly feels that the Conference must endorse and reinforce the Union's common objectives, which aim at peace and freedom, internal and external security, democracy, protection of the human rights and prosperity for the citizens of Europe and solidarity between them.

Flexibility, its rationale and its limits

13. The success of this ever-closer Union among the peoples of Europe depends, as we have seen, on its ability to meet citizens' demands. However, it must also be based on common principles which must be reaffirmed. They inspire the common core which characterizes the Community as an entity based on the rule of law, and in particular involve:

It should be emphasized that respect for these two principles should constitute an adequate response to the growing need for consistency of action by the Union as a whole, irrespective of the outcome of the Conference on the options of a bicephalous Union/Community structure, division into Treaty "pillars", or unification.

14. On the basis of this common core, the prospect of enlargement and the existence in the Union of differentiated integration arrangements, raises the question of flexibility and its limits in relation to the outcome of the Conference and the approach to be adopted to enlargement. An unequivocal answer to the question "What do we want to accomplish together?" will clarify what the reform is expected to achieve. If a common will is ultimately found to be lacking, that should not prevent those who wish and even need to make the Union progress from doing so subject to clear limits. It will have to be considered on a case-by-case basis and when necessary what should be the allowed flexibility that will make it possible for the Union to manage diversity without jeopardizing the "acquis" and the common objectives.

15. Therefore, the Group rejects any formula which could lead to an à la carte Europe. As regards the guidelines to allow flexibility, there is a large majority view sharing the following criteria:

Several members, while agreeing with most of the above, stress that such flexible arrangements in the Union should only be possible when agreed by all, as in the past. Some members believe that, whereas such arrangements should in principle be temporary, they need not always be so, especially where they do not concern "core disciplines" of the EC.

16. It should be pointed out however that the degrees of flexibility admissible are different both under each of the three "pillars" and also in the case of the present Member States and those acceding on next enlargement:

C. CONTEXT AND TIMETABLE

17.The Conference is not an isolated event. It forms part of a broader context parallel to the Conference in some respects and subsequent to it in others. This context includes, inter alia, the following elements which will form Europe's agenda up to the end of the century:

18. The comprehensive examination of the best way to manage Europe's agenda up to the end of the century has been taken on personally by the members of the European Council, i.e. Europe's highest level of political leadership. All the above points, although having their own momentum, are clearly linked in one way or another to the reform of the Union; it will therefore be necessary to consider the relationship between them, so that they can be achieved without obstructing one another.

To sum up, only once the 1996 Conference has reached a satisfactory conclusion will it be possible for the other tasks to be tackled on more solid bases, although this does not prevent appropriate preparatory work from being carried out at the same time. The Group therefore considers that the Conference should start and conclude its proceedings in good time in order to enable the other important elements on the schedule to be dealt with properly.

19. We have already seen that enlargement is a response by the Union to the new challenges facing the continent of Europe. However, as we shall see below, it is also a challenge in itself. This is because of its threefold impact on an institutional system conceived for the six founding States, on the internal and external security of the Union and on the need to preserve and strengthen the Community as an entity based on the rule of law. It is furthermore possible that enlargement will also have a definite impact on Community policies and give a new dimension to the problem of the Union's resources.

20. Therefore, the Group above all agrees in stressing that enlargement must take place but it has to be duly prepared so that it is successfully achieved. To avoid enlargement or have it miscarry would create a serious crisis not only in the applicant countries but also in the present Union.

Who will be acceding to the Union when enlargement takes place? It is clear that accession should be open to all European countries wishing to accede which comply with the criteria laid down at the Copenhagen European Council. Each case must be dealt with on its own merits during the negotiations. However, the aim of the Reflection Group is to identify the reforms desirable and sufficient to enable the Union to incorporate associated Central and Eastern European countries, including the Baltic States, Cyprus and Malta.

When? In accordance with the conclusions of the Essen European Council, negotiations with the associated States of Central and Eastern Europe, including the Baltic States which fulfil the above criteria, can only start after the Conference has ended. In accordance with those of the Cannes European Council, Cyprus and Malta will start six months after the end of the Conference taking into account its outcome.

How? The next enlargement will have to combine a global approach to meet common demands with flexible adjustment structures which make it possible in each case to adopt an appropriate time scale for the process of full incorporation of applicants into the present Union's common policies.

21. The question of whether and if so how common policies should be revised in the light of enlargement is not within the Group's mandate. There is, however, agreement on the need to maintain the "acquis communautaire" and build on it (Articles B and N) as a basic principle for the present Member States and as a major guide for the applicant countries. This should not prevent progressive implementation of the "acquis" by the applicant countries.

A broad majority of members of the Group favours the separation of the Conference exercise from the study of the impact of enlargement in relation to future development of common policies, for the following three reasons: firstly, a revision of policies does not require amendment of their respective legal bases; secondly, the effect of enlargement on common policies will not be immediate but will be spread over time in accordance with the model for enlargement which in general seems possible for the next set of applicants; finally, it is not appropriate to combine two such politically sensitive exercises.

Some members consider that the analysis of the impact of the enlargement on policies and resources should be developed simultaneously with IGC. One member stresses that, each of the EU's major tasks from now until the end of the century are aspects of the same overall strategy, the results of which will be judged with an assessment of all the efforts, concessions and opportunities involved in the common project.

D. WHAT KIND OF CONFERENCE?

The scope of the Conference. The need for transparency

22. The Group considers that the Conference should formulate adequate responses to the above challenges. This means that on top of improving the present functioning of the Union it must make the reforms necessary to incorporate into the Union a greater number of Member States than was the case in earlier enlargements. The forthcoming enlargement will make the Union much more heterogeneous than at present as regards differences in size of countries, variety of languages, disparity of income levels and differing sensitivities with regard to Foreign Policy or Justice and Home Affairs.

The Maastricht Treaty foresees a specific scope for the Conference. As seen above, this scope has subsequently been enlarged at various European Councils. The Heads of State or Government have identified the need to make institutional reforms as an important issue of the Conference in order to improve the efficiency, democracy and transparency of the Union. According to these elements, the Group has convened that the scope of the Conference should be targeted to deliver the necessary results without opening a general revision of the Treaty.

23. The Group favours comprehensive treatment of all the Conference issues as part of a single exercise. A single Conference keeping a general vision of the essential issues and which is not split seems the most appropriate method of achieving consistent results able to cope with challenges facing the Union.

24. It should also be emphasized that the necessary results can be achieved by amending the Treaties and also by improving the Union's procedures and working methods. The Cannes European Council has recommended the Group to bear in mind the advantages of seeking improvements in the working of the Institutions that do not require any amendment to the Treaties and can thus enter into force without delay. It should be pointed out, however, that in the report often the proposals for practical improvements refer to matters that, according to alternative options, should be subject to Treaty reforms. The choice between them is not of technical but political nature, since they express a different level of political ambition for the Union.

25. It is also considered that the proceedings of the 1996 IGC should be as transparent as possible. The concerns of the Institutions, the organizations representing civil society and the future applicants must be given an appropriate hearing. The public must also be provided with all important information enabling it to follow closely a discussion which is directly relevant to citizens' fundamental concerns. This is essential, not only so that citizens can feel that they are participating in the construction of Europe but also because their opinions are essential for carrying out the reform.

26. The Group is aware that, if citizens consider the reform inappropriate or insufficient or feel that they were not involved in it by means of adequate information, it will run the risk of not being approved. As the reforms resulting from the Conference are an essential part of Europe's agenda until the end of the century, the Group stresses the importance of holding a Conference the content and course of which meets the expectations on the basis of which it was convened. We consider that there is therefore an obligation to achieve sufficient results, and this obligation must be met by the Parties to the Conference.

27. In the light of the above points and of its mandate, the Group considers that the Conference should confine itself to its own specific aims, namely realizing the (legal or practical) reforms to enable the Union to meet the current challenges facing Europe, continuing and building on the achievements of Maastricht and preparing the ground for the forthcoming enlargement.

The Conference will moreover form part of an open process. It is an important step in the process but will certainly not be the last. The Union will continue to develop in the future after the 1996 Conference.

28. Against this background, the Group without seeking to limit the Conference's sovereign power, recommends that results should be achieved in three main areas:


| Home |

© Enlargement