The Greek position on the Agenda 2000". Athens, 8 September 1997
1. A GENERAL APPROACH
The Greek government welcomes with enthusiasm the future enlargement of the European Union, which will include the TEN CEE countries, and Cyprus. It believes that this target has to be completed with appropriate conditions in order to secure the enlargement process of the EU with the eleven countries. A basic point for Greece is to ensure that the enlargement process includes as many states as possible. The beginning of the negotiations should take place simultaneously and should include all the eleven candidate countries, irrespective of their different timing for the final accession. Greece had opposed the Commission's proposal to start the negotiations only with a small number of states. Greece claimed that no differentiation should be made, since none of the candidate countries entirely fulfils the criteria posed by the EU, except the political one. For this reason, the decision of the Luxembourg Summit to start negotiations with all the eleven countries (Cyprus + 10 CEE countries) was welcomed by Greece. At the same time, the Greek government supports all the efforts initiated by the Union to make easier the accession of the candidate countries. To this respect, Greece considers that " accession partnerships" will play a very important role for the enlargement process. Greece supports the development of bilateral relations with the candidate countries and considers that the Phare programme will also play a very important role in the institutional building of the candidate countries. As far as the European Conference is concerned, and recognising that it was created in order to give Turkey the opportunity to participate, the Greek government maintains that the participation of one state in the European Conference, implies that this state fulfil all the conditions and requirements. It has also made clear that no exception will be accepted. A point that the Greek side tried to make clear in Luxembourg concerning the European Conference was that Greece will not accept any kind of "different approaches" on the issue of the EU-Turkish relations. They have to be based on the formal EU standards. If Turkey wants to become the twelve-candidate country it has to fulfil the criteria of Copenhagen, which are the same for every candidate country.
2. GREECE'S MAIN OBJECTIVES
Contrary to the western and northern EU member states, Greece does not have direct interests in the accession of the PECO countries to the EU. In fact, Greece may have losses on the economic field (especially in agriculture) as a substantial number of the EU funds will be absorbed by economically disadvantaged eastern states. Despite this fact, the Greek government supports the enlargement. It may not have substantial direct interests but indirectly Greece may also benefit greatly by exchanging its support for the PECO countries with the support of the other European in the matters that are the main Greek demands: the beginning of negotiations with Cyprus; the promotion of the interests of the two Balkan states, Romania and Bulgaria; and of course the attitude of the EU towards Turkey and its will to be the twelfth candidate country.
2.1. GREECE AND THE BALKAN STATES
Greece is called to play an important role in this respect. It is the only country in the Balkan peninsula which has a stable democratic regime, while being a more developed economy and at the same time is closer to the other Balkan states not only geographically but also in terms of culture, behaviour and history. At the same time is the only state in the region, which is a full member of the EU and NATO, which implies increased responsibilities. Lately, Greece has been called to take some important initiatives to promote stability and peace in the Balkans. Incidently, Greece claimed that the Greek attitude towards the Serbs during the civil war period in Yugoslavia was misunderstood by the international community as well as on the question of the name of the FYROM. However, regardless of who was right the West has interpreted the Greek external policy especially concerning FYROM as entirely based on sentimentalism and internal political differences. In fact, Greece has more reasons to worry about the situation in Balkans. First of all, as a Balkan state itself, Greece wants peace and stability, because everything that happens to a neighbour country, has a direct impact on the own Greece. Secondly, Greek enterprises, public and privates, have made great investments in the neighbouring countries. Greece today is one of the three biggest investing countries in the area, and at the same time a large number of economic refugees work there and contribute to payments balance of their countries. For all these reasons, the beginning of the negotiations of the EU with Bulgaria and Romania and their future accession to the Union is in the interest of Greece. In such an occasion the EU will become the base not only for the political and economic stability of the two states but also for the security in the region. The role of Greece will be upgraded during the negotiation process as its European character allows Greece to play this relevant role. Finally, the economic development of those countries as well as the stability and peace in the area are also in the great interest of Greece.
2.2. GREECE AND CYPRUS
There is no doubt that Greece is the most ardent supporter of the Cypriot application for membership in the EU. That is the main target and demand of Greek European foreign policy. The enlargement process with Cyprus already started during the first months of 1997. Now the basic point of interest is to determine both how long this process will last and what the result will be. The European Community agreed to start negotiations with Cyprus although the Cyprus matter is still unsolved. In any case, the fact is that a direct and fast solution to the political problem under the aegis of the Secretary General of the UN would be preferred, as well as the participation of the Turkish -Cypriots in the negotiations. The Greek government expects that the negotiations for the accession of Cyprus in the EU will play a decisive role for the solution of the political problem.
The Greek position on the accession of Cyprus to the EU is clear. Greece wants the negotiations to be continued and it is not going to accept any political or technical intervention from any partner member state, which would target to delay the negotiation process with Cyprus. In that case Greece will use the veto in order to delay or stop the negotiation process of the countries of Central and Eastern Europe. Greece's positive attitude towards those countries tries to get a correlative positive attitude of the member states mostly interested in the eastern enlargement on matters which are in the interest of Greece, and especially negotiations with Cyprus. As the Greek Foreign Minister, had recently declared," Cyprus was raised as an enlargement issue before enlargement with Scandinavian countries and in the normal course of events it could have been included in the Sweden, Finland, Austria and Norway package and would now be a member of the EU. Now Cyprus is the No 1 candidate. If anyone creates a political issue over Cyprus, they create a political issue of the functioning of the Community as a whole and if there is no Community functioning there is no enlargement".
2.3. GREECE AND TURKEY
The question of the European orientation of Turkey is a very sensitive one not only in Greece but also in all member states. In the case of Greece, there is a deeper interest as the two countries have many past and deep differences: mainly the Cyprus problem and the question of the Aegean islands. Greece is not willing to accept any kind of negotiations concerning the admission of Turkey to the group of the candidate states unless there is an improvement and a solution to the major differences faced by the two neighbouring countries. At the same time, Greece reminds that Turkey does not fulfil the preconditions set out at the European Council in Copenhagen in 1993 in order to participate to the enlargement process. That is, Turkey is politically unable to join the EU because of the continuous violation of human rights as in the cases of Kurds, Islamists and the banned parties of those groups. There is no existence of freedom of press, since many journalists are jailed or even killed, and of course it is unacceptable that in Turkey, unlike all democratic states, the armed forces control, instead of being controlled by, the government. Finally in the economic field, yearly inflation rates are up to 80%. Under those circumstances, Turkey has not yet been accepted as a candidate ready for negotiations by all the member states. Furthermore, in some cases some of them try to hide themselves behind Greece's back instead of presenting directly their opposition to the Turkish application.
On the other hand, Greece recognises and accepts that there must exist a European perspective for Turkey. But still considers very important to settle the major differences that divide the two neighbouring countries, something, which presupposes concessions by both states. At present, and in spite of the initiatives presented by the EU and the USA for the improvement of the Greek-Turkish relations, Turkey upholds a provocative attitude towards Greece by contesting the 'Greekness' of Greek islands, by breaking into Greek airspace and by displaying intransigence and inadmissible behaviour over Cyprus. Greece will make sure that all relations between Turkey and the EU are broken off until the Turks withdraw even the last trace of claim against Greece; until they admit that Greek islands are Greek; until they accept the right of Greece to extend its territorial waters to 12 miles; until they agree to its airspace; until they are willing to participate to the solution of the political problem in Cyprus and all the other things that are grounded in law and based on history. According to a recent statement by the Greek Foreign Minister, "Turkey is the only state in the world which lays claim to the right to enter into a process of bargaining based only on the balance of power and not on the principles or international law. Turkey is violating International Law and is avoiding the international courts". Finally, it is obvious that the Cyprus problem greatly affects Greek-Turkish relations. Turkey tries to take advantage of the enlargement negotiations of EU with Cyprus and the willing of the Greek-Cypriot side to find a solution to the political problem, in order to succeed the recognition of the illegal occupied territories of the northern Cyprus by the Turkish army. At the same time Greece is continuously under pressure from the USA in order to settle for the admission of Turkey to EU. Greece has strongly reacted, and its Foreign Minister declared that USA as non-member of the EU, couldn't lay down the terms on which enlargement will take place or influence it. Of course, Greek government recognises the fact that the United States can play a major role in Greek-Turkish relations and in the resolution of the Cyprus problem but they have nothing to do with the enlargement of the EU. That is something which concerns only the European Union states.
3 CONCLUSION
Greece is in favour of the enlargement of the European Union including the ten CEE states and Cyprus, and supports ardently the enlargement of the Union as a very important historic and political moment for the European continent. At the same time, Greece defends its own interests which have basically to do with the admission of Cyprus into the EU in the first wave of the enlargement process, the good course of the negotiations between the two candidate Balkan states and the EU and of course the matter of Turkey's application for accession in the Union. Especially in the matters of Cyprus and Turkey, Greece has made clear that it is not going to make any kind of concessions despite the pressures of some EU states and even the United States. The reason is that Turkey is not just a question of economic, political or diplomatic interests. It is also a national case as Greek-Turkish relations are based on a continuous provocative and threatening behaviour by Turkey, which by using its power wants to bargain the Greekness of a number of historically, proved Greek territories. The Greek government and the Greek people are not willing to make any kind of concession and they do not until their rights and their demands are consolidated.
( 1) Néanmoins, les opinions reprises dans ce document reflettent uniquement les perceptions de leurs auteurs et n'engagent pas le parlement europeen en tant qu'institution ni les sources ci-dessus mentionées. Par ailleurs, le texte complèt de la plupart des documents cités peut aussi être consulté soit via INTRANET à l'adresse: http://www.europarl.ep.ec/enlargement soit via INTERNET à l'adresse: http://www.europarl.europa.eu/enlargement
This paper is also mainly based on the Press Conference of the Greek Prime Minister Konstantinos Simitis given in Luxembourg on 13 December 1997, as well as on the Interview with Mr. Theodoros Pagalos, Minister of Foreign Affairs in Athens on 30 April 1998.