Speech
delivered by the President of the European Parliament,
Mr José María GIL-ROBLES
to the European Council
on Wednesday, 24 March 1999
in Berlin

As delivered


LADIES AND GENTLEMEN

How often have we been told that the Union has reached a crucial moment in its history. That the Union is standing at the crossroads. How all too often have we heard these phrases? But the simple fact is that European integration is a series of crossroads, key moments, crises and last-minute solutions.

And today we are once again standing at the crossroads. I am sure, however, that you will find the right way forward from here. Parliament offers the conclusions it has arrived at, as it has done consistently, as its contribution to your deliberations.

I will deal with Agenda 2000 first of all, given that it will undoubtedly be the priority issue at today's meeting, as Parliament highlighted at its sitting yesterday.

When addressing you recently at Petersberg, I drew your attention to the major contribution made by the European Parliament in examining in depth every single one of the Commission proposals comprising the Agenda 2000 package, and in submitting a coherent body of reports on this complex and enormously important body of proposals.

Parliament has not restricted itself to submitting a collection of opinions. It has initiated an unprecedented series of talks with the Council with a view to reconciling the two institutions' differences. The President-in-Office referred to these talks when informing Parliament, on 10 March, of the preparations for today's Council meeting and I should like to take this opportunity to thank Chancellor Schroeder for his personal undertaking to pursue this intense, interactive dialogue with Parliament. At the same time, I should also like to thank the British and the Austrian Presidencies, which established the entire procedure. The process has turned out to be genuinely constructive. It has helped bring both sides closer together on the basis of an open exchange of information and, I trust, will enable the European Council to reach a balanced consensus on this wide-ranging and complex package of measures.

I went through the issues at Petersberg, and I have no intention of subjecting you to a repetition today. At that meeting we established very clearly what these issues are, and they have been hammered home by my Vice-Presidents and the chairmen of Parliament's committees at their meetings with the Council and Commission.

Nonetheless, if Parliament is to complete the task it has undertaken before the forthcoming European elections, there are two points I must underline.

Firstly, I reminded you at Petersberg that there are only 25 working days between this Council here in Berlin and the European Parliament's May part-session. Parliament has established an intensive calendar of meetings in order to meet this very tight deadline.

It is therefore essential that the European Council's position on the entire Agenda 2000 package be established today, so that the corresponding texts can be finalised and delivered on 13 April.

Secondly, with regard to agriculture and fisheries, the Council should once again formally consult Parliament on the Commission's amended proposals or such amendments as the Council itself may unanimously decide to make to those proposals.

For example, with regard to the issue of CAP funding, the Agriculture, Finance and Foreign Affairs Councils have all discussed this subject of co-funding and decreasing expenditure. However, no new proposals have so far been submitted to Parliament.

These issues may strike you as technicalities, but in fact they are of central importance if agreement is to be reached in good time. Parliament therefore calls on the Council to organise as many meetings between Parliament and the relevant Councils of Ministers as may be necessary in order to reach agreement.

xxxx

And now I will return, briefly, to the basic issues, but limit my comments to developments since the Petersberg meeting.

In its dialogue with the Council, Parliament has had a genuine opportunity clearly to establish exactly what its priorities are. And I believe that in reaching agreement on agriculture, the Ministers have taken into account some of Parliament's major concerns. This applies particularly to the price cuts, which are less severe than originally proposed, and spread over a longer period. The Council has responded to Parliament's concern that the Commission had gone too far in its proposals to try to reduce the scope of the intervention mechanisms. The agreement on wine, for example, does to some extent acknowledge the need for greater flexibility which Parliament highlighted. However, the Council has not backed Parliament with regard to the ceilings on aid to larger farms.

Parliament notes that there has been substantial progress on Structural Policy with regard to simplifying and concentrating the Funds. The Council and Parliament are in general agreement with regard to reducing both the number of Objectives and the number of Community initiatives. Nonetheless, Parliament continues to advocate the continuity of the URBAN initiative. We also welcome the progress made in the direction of Parliament's position on the efficiency reserve, the horizontal nature of Objective 3 and the important issue of assessment and control.

With regard to the Cohesion Fund, major issues remain undecided, for example, its overall funding and the aid percentages. However, we should welcome the decision on its continuity and the eligibility criteria, as proof that the goal of cohesion and solidarity between the Member States is an essential part of Union integration.

The progress already made towards achieving consensus on the Social Fund Regulation proposal takes up, in part, what Parliament said months ago. By that I mean issues such as concentrating the scope, the objective of supporting measures to prevent and combat unemployment, equality between men and women, and equal opportunities in the labour market for those affected by social exclusion. We also welcome the proposal to make subsidies available to local projects out of this Fund.

In the context of the open and constructive dialogue established with the Council, Parliament is aware of the very satisfactory progress that there has been with respect to the Agenda 2000 pillar devoted to pre-accession, particularly as regards the coordination regulation and the pre-accession instrument.

xxxxx

We come now to a particularly testing problem: how we are to fund the Union over the next seven years.

The challenge that the European Council is facing consists of coming to a recommendation for the financial framework for the European Union for the next seven years that:

  • does not hobble the Union and its institutions, but allows them to fulfil the tasks that have been allocated to the Union under the Treaties, while respecting rigorous budget and administrative limits;
  • provides sufficient funding for each of the major categories of expenditure according to the current activities of the Union - and in particular foresees realistic levels of funding in headings for internal policies, external actions and administration, 46.5 billion for internal policies, 36.9 billion for external actions and 35.1 billion for administration over the period 2000 - 2006;
  • gassures Parliament of a degree of flexibility in funding for currently unforeseeable actions of about 0.015% of GNP on average each year (remember that the budget for 1999 totals 1.10% of GNP);
  • makes closer cooperation between the two institutions possible, thereby enabling them to give their opinion on the budget as a whole through an extended conciliation procedure. This would make it easier to reach agreement on issues such as the classification of expenditure on particular budget lines;
  • and lastly, does not set the financing of the Union at a level inferior to that which can be achieved merely by applying Article 203 of the EC Treaty.

This is no mean feat, but it is certainly not impossible. Our hope is that it can be achieved if we endeavour to reach a consensus, acting in the interests of the Community as a whole.

xxxxx

I would now like to move on to the Commission's resignation en masse and its impact.

On Tuesday evening Parliament adopted a resolution calling on this extraordinary Council meeting to involve it in setting a precise and reasonable timetable for the appointment of the new Commission:

  • it also calls on the governments of the Member States to submit their nominee for Commission President without delay and subsequently to nominate the other Members of the Commission;
  • it draws attention to the fact that, in accordance with the Treaty, the Commission appointed now will remain in office until the current term has expired, that is to say until the end of this year;
  • lastly, it stresses that the procedures established by the Amsterdam Treaty should apply to the approval of both the Commission appointed now and its successor, which will take office on 1 January 2000.

The aforementioned resolution is a response to the need to find a way out of the current situation as soon as possible. As matters stand, the outgoing Commission's responsibilities are confined to current or urgent business, whereas the Union needs a Commission which is in full command. Merely appointing a new President for the future whilst allowing the existing Commission to remain in office until August would not be a solution, since the political imperative to replace several Commissioners is coupled with the need, from the legal standpoint, for the Commission to regain Parliament's confidence if it is to carry out all its responsibilities properly.

As regards the appointment of the Commission President, I wish also to stress that although the Amsterdam Treaty has not yet entered into force, the European Council applied the procedure provided for in that Treaty when Mr Santer was appointed, with Parliament's consent, which goes to show that Parliament is now being asked for its approval rather than its opinion. Taking a step backwards now would be inconceivable.

On the other hand, the procedure under which the Commissioners are subject to scrutiny by Parliament and the vote of approval of the Commission as a body are dealt with in exactly the same way in both Treaties.

In the aforementioned resolution, Parliament also emphasised the need for the Commission to launch an ambitious and comprehensive programme to introduce radical reforms to its financial management and financial control procedures and to its management practices as a whole, with a view to introducing appropriate and improved standards for the management of European affairs, taking transparency as its guiding principle.

xxxx

As regards reform and transparency, Parliament has also been putting its own house in order, which is why it has submitted a draft Statute for Members to the Council and approved a Commission proposal to establish the legal basis required to draw up a scheme for Members' assistants.

I would like to express my thanks to the Council Presidency for its resolute and swift action in taking up these matters, and to mention the spirit of dialogue and cooperation in which the Danish Government and Parliament are seeking solutions to the main concerns raised by the people of Denmark with regard to the Statute for Members.

It is my view that there is a growing awareness of the need to resolve these issues by the time the Amsterdam Treaty enters into force.

xxxx

I would like to conclude, Ladies and Gentlemen, by referring to the resolution which Parliament adopted yesterday, in which it called on the Member States to deposit their instruments of ratification of the Amsterdam Treaty as soon as possible.

The current institutional crisis presents the European Union with an opportunity to assert its political and democratic credentials, make the Commission more accountable to Parliament and pave the way for a new and strong Commission with a sense of responsibility and political muscle. Both institutions are indispensable. You cannot strengthen the Commission against Parliament's will or without its trust.

I trust that in working together we will be able to achieve these aims to the benefit of all the citizens of Europe.

Many thanks.


© European Parliament: 24 march 1999