Speech
by the President of the European Parliament
Klaus Hänsch
to the European Council
on Friday, 9 and
Saturday, 10 December 1994
in Essen

Check against delivery


Mr President of the European Council,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Do not expect me now to present a list of demands from the European Parliament. Do not expect complaints about the European Parliament's inadequate rights. I am grateful for the opportunity which you have given me to set out for you the majority positions of the Union institution which can be sure, as you yourselves can, of democratic legitimacy through elections.

I.

The Treaty of Maastricht has been in force for one year. In a number of respects, it has turned out to be better than it was made out to be. It has given the European Parliament co-decision rights. Parliament must now make use of these new rights, and flesh them out, if it wishes to have them extended in 1996. Immediately after it was elected, then, Parliament made a start on reforming its own proceedings with a view to making them more effective and more transparent. We have not only tightened up working procedures and improved attendance. We have given priority to making use of our co-decision rights (under Article 189b of the Treaty on European Union) within the Community's legislative process. Twenty acts have already been adopted (of which only six required conciliation between the Council and Parliament). Of 98 other acts, the Council has established a common position on only 56 to date. Parliament is prepared, and in a position, to gear itself by 1996 to the complicated Article 189b procedure in such a way that parliamentary involvement, guaranteed under the Treaty, proves successful and the Union's decision-taking ability is not weakened - at least not by Parliament.

The manner in which Parliament has carried out the process of consultation on the appointment of the Commission President has been such that, in particular following the irritation felt when the candidate was nominated, it has been given a political significance going far beyond mere consultation.

The vote of confidence in the Commission as a whole will be preceded by public hearings for the individual candidates in Parliament's committees.

That will serve as a model for the future. And it is perfectly obvious that the new procedure will create a new interrelationship between Commission and Parliament.

Allow me at this point to thank you and President Delors for having accepted my decision, after initial hesitation, not to have the vote of confidence taken until January, instead of in December, and for extending the term of office of the old Commission by two weeks. This makes it possible for Parliament to involve the new colleagues from Austria, Finland and Sweden in the vote of confidence in the new Commission on a fully fledged basis.

With regard to fleshing out the Treaty of Maastricht, however, I am bound to point out that we still have a number of interinstitutional agreements to conclude - some of which, or so we hope, while Germany still holds the Council presidency.

What we have initially found with the Treaty of Maastricht is not negative. It is only the first pillar, however, where, despite some shortcomings, clear progress has been made. As regards the Common Foreign and Security Policy, but above all in home affairs and judicial policy, there can be no question of progress having been made.

Parliament is concerned that the Union is failing in, of all areas, internal security - in a policy area which is rightly of such importance to citizens. It turns out that intergovernmental cooperation simply is not a better tool for bringing about common decisions. Parliament would draw attention to the commitment represented by the Europol Convention; it likewise expects full freedom of movement in the Union to be achieved, at last, in line with the commitments which the Member States have entered into.

I do not propose, either, to keep quiet achievements: for many years, the European Parliament has been calling for racism and xenophobia to be combated at Union level too. By setting up the advisory commission on combating racism and xenophobia, you have taken a first important step. Let us now take the second. As proposed by that commission, give the go-ahead for Union-wide legislation enabling racism and xenophobia to be combated in the Member States in a coordinated and efficient manner.

An efficient European Union must target its resources, and it must effectively verify how they are deployed. It must also put an end to the various forms of fraud through which Community funding is unlawfully obtained. I would point out that, in addition to the traditional checks, it is now possible to have lump sum or penalty payments imposed by the Court of Justice.

European Union expenditure is predominantly administered by national authorities. It is therefore the national administrations which are being defrauded in the overwhelming number of cases. Close cooperation between the Union and the Member States is all the more urgently required in combating fraud.

I propose that we organize a conference - European 'Assizes' - to bring together specialists from various levels with a view to coordinating their work more effectively and hence to ensuring that the fraudulent use of EU funding is combated at all levels on a genuinely common basis.

II.

Since it was established, the Community has stood for increased prosperity.

Not simply for this reason, but it is one of the reasons, it has enjoyed the support of the large majority of citizens of the Member States of the Union for three decades.

Today it must point to a way out of structural unemployment and focus its actions on job creation if it wishes to retain that support.

The 18 million unemployed men and women in our Union, and there are at least that many, are not only 18 million tragic cases of poverty, exclusion, and personal and family humiliation. Persistent unemployment also undermines confidence in justice and democracy and hence the stability of our societies.

In 1993, in Copenhagen, you gave the highest priority to a coordinated approach by the Union and the Member States on combating unemployment in our nations. In doing so, you coupled the Union's good standing with employment policy success. You have aroused expectations which you must not disappoint.

The Commission's White Paper on growth, competition and employment has demonstrated what contribution the European Union can make towards combating unemployment and has at the same time made it clear that the main burden lies with the Member States.

No one underestimates the difficulty involved in creating 15 million new jobs by the year 2000; but if, by 1996, we are unable to point to initial success at least, we need not bother in the first place about consulting the nations about the outcome of the intergovernmental conference. It will then be a matter of complete indifference to them what fine objectives, integration models and institutional frameworks we propose to them for the Union of the future.

To be sure, Europe is experiencing an economic upturn that is more robust than could have been expected at the beginning of the year. Unemployment has remained unbearably high, however, and there are no signs that there will be an appreciable reduction simply because of favourable economic activity.

The most important European resource - namely individuals' willingness and ability to work - continues to be inadequately utilized.

The economic upturn continues to be insufficiently rooted in our own efforts and too greatly rooted in increased demand for European goods and services, above all in the developing countries of Asia, Central and Eastern Europe and Latin America. We realize that we must not rely on this external shot in the arm and that this is not enough to secure our global competitiveness on a sustained basis.

If the European market absorbs more than 90% of what we produce in terms of goods and services, we must enhance, and make use of, this potential first and foremost for growth and employment.

The European Parliament insists that the measures proposed by the Commission in the White Paper and action plan should actually be carried out. That is our most urgent appeal to you. We must not allow ourselves to be blinded by the embryonic economic upturn. We must not lose sight of what was acknowledged to be necessary during the crisis: the restructuring of the European economy.

The first thing to be done is to take account of the ever-increasing demand for high-skill labour and services by increasing capacities for education and training in the Member States.

Secondly, surplus savings in the private sector - 5 to 6% of gross domestic product - must be mobilized for investment in new jobs. In this way, millions of people will be taken out of the welfare benefit recipients' camp and moved into the marketplace of the economy.

Not only might that at the same time help us to reduce government deficits, but, thirdly, it would also create the political environment for further cuts in interest rates and hence enable further investment to be made in modernizing Europe's productive apparatus.

Contrary to what some might believe, the European Parliament is not interested in neo-Keynesian strategies for stimulating business activity. What we are interested in is stimulating investment - through the Union's policy-making - in areas which will strengthen the competitiveness of the European economy.

What is at stake here is a series of major projects for 21st century society which are intended to secure our own future and that of our children. If people in the Member States, in future, associate the European Union with such projects, we shall win them back to the project to unite Europe.

The European Parliament therefore backs the Commission's action plan, and backs the proposed financing of the trans-European networks, including arrangements going beyond Community budgetary orthodoxy.

We realize that we cannot finance everything and that nor should we; this, at least, we must finance, however.

Without delay, the preliminary work by the Christophersen group should be turned into an ordinary legislative process so that it can be freely discussed by the Union's institutions, adopted and financed.

If we invest in the structural renewal of our economy, we should do so in such a way that, in the process, we also improve our track record on the environment.

What is preventing us from combining the fascinating prospects of large-scale projects in transport, energy production and telecommunications with ecological renewal?

Only through a concerted effort can we alter our tax systems in such a way that the tax burden on the use of labour is lightened and the burden on energy consumption and on draining environmental resources is increased. The European Parliament calls for the Community-wide introduction of the CO2 tax. Make it possible. And let us begin to clean our seas, the Baltic, the North Sea and the Mediterranean - a major project in respect of which funding is less important than coordination and a common political will.

Together we have more latitude than is sometimes assumed. Our firms are geared much more to Europe than to the world as a whole.

That allows us, together, to conduct an active employment policy and, together, to lay down improved environmental standards.

Of course, we must make sure that we can afford them. Of course, European products must not become so expensive that they are displaced by rivals with lower standards. Those rivals must also survive on our market, however, where they must observe our common standards. Furthermore, by laying down higher environmental standards we shall create new markets on which European firms can become the leaders.

III.

The referendums in Austria, Finland and Sweden have underscored the Union's attractiveness in an impressive fashion. It remains attractive further afield - eastwards and southwards.

The Commission has delivered a favourable opinion on the applications by Cyprus and Malta and Parliament has endorsed them. In 1993, in Copenhagen, the European Council opened up the prospect of accession for the associated states of Central and Eastern Europe. It is therefore no longer at all relevant whether we wish to 'deepen or widen' the Union. Of our own doing, we now face the decision as to whether we wish to deepen it or whether we have it broken up into a 'mere free trade area'. If the price for enlargement were to be a watering down or indeed a break up of the Union as it now stands, it is a price that ought not to be paid. It would be too high - not only for the present Member States, but also for those which wish to join, since they in particular wish to join a Union that works. They, in particular, need a Union which offers solidarity.

Therefore not only must the Central and Eastern European states be capable of joining, but the Union itself must also make itself able to be enlarged: by tightening up our decision-taking procedures, by making our Community policies more flexible, by spelling out and asserting the principle of subsidiarity and by broadening the parliamentary legitimacy of Union policy-making.

This also holds true for reform of the Common Agricultural Policy and of the Structural Funds, the financing of which cannot be ensured if we simply extrapolate them unreformed within an enlarged Union.

Parliament regards enlargement of the Union as desirable and as inevitable. We realize, however, that we need time until further European states become full members and that there are a number of stages in this process.

We can expand the existing links and develop them further. The European Parliament advocates structured dialogue and the creation of an ever closer network of bilateral treaties. We must do our utmost to expand and deepen our relations with our neighbouring regions as carefully as possible, but also as dynamically as possible. This applies not only to Central and Eastern Europe but also, in particular, to the entire Mediterranean.

With regard to relations with the Eastern and Central European states, in connection with enlargement, I should like to make two proposals. Next year I propose to consult the Presidents of the Parliaments of the Central and Eastern European states on how we can provide a solid common framework for parliamentary cooperation, which has already begun through our joint parliamentary committees, and expand existing contacts.

And in 1996 the Union could point the way forward in a directly effective manner. To date, under the Treaty of Maastricht, third states may be associated only with the EC Treaty, that is to say: economic association. By making a minor change in the Treaty on European Union, let us make it possible for states to be associated with the European Union and hence in terms of the Common Foreign and Security Policy and collaborative arrangements in the area of home affairs and judicial policy.

In conclusion, I should like to thank the Council presidency, Federal Chancellor Kohl and Foreign Minister Kinkel, and all their colleagues for their efforts to deepen the Council's relations with the European Parliament in a spirit of cooperation. We are counting on developing them further under the French presidency of the Council, with mutual respect for the different duties we are required to discharge within the Union.


© European Parliament: 1998