Speech
by the President of the European Parliament
José María Gil-Robles
to the European Council
on Friday, 12 December
in Luxembourg

As Delivered


Mr President, Members of the European Council,

Before going on to the major subjects which this European Council will be tackling today and tomorrow, I think we should welcome the agreement reached by the Community institutions on establishing the procedure for selecting the countries which will join the third phase of Economic and Monetary Union on 1 January 1999. The consultation procedure agreed on will mean that this enormously important decision will be subject to essential democratic control.

We should also welcome the fact that Council and Parliament have reached an agreement on the procedure for appointing the Members of the Executive Committee of the European Central Bank. In both cases, Parliament has undertaken to respect very short consultation deadlines. this demonstrates once again that increased democratic control does not mean that the efficiency of the decision-making process suffers.

This European Council is essentially concerned with two subjects, namely, the coordination of the Member States' economic policies and the putting in hand of the process of enlarging the European Union.

As regards the first of these subjects, the European Parliament has adopted no resolution whatever. I will therefore refrain from putting forward proposals.

However, I think I should recall certain principles which our institution has repeatedly defended with regard to reinforced cooperation, since the participation of only some of the Member States in Economic and Monetary Union clearly presupposes reinforced cooperation.

Parliament has always insisted that we must seek to reduce to a minimum the differentiation between Member States involved in any form of reinforced cooperation. In other words, it is possible that those States which adopt the Euro on 1 January 1999 may find themselves in heaven, but it would be a very bad think if those who do not find themselves stuck in limbo or, even worse, in purgatory.

In practice, this means that decisions must essentially be adopted within the body common to all Member States, i.e. the Council. And not merely formally adopted, but in real terms, that is to say without a systematic adumbration of majorities or a block of 'ins' in forums other than the Council itself. That is what both the Treaty and the principle of loyal cooperation between Member States demand.

Of course, those States which join the third stage of Economic and Monetary Union may well be interested in coordinating - amongst themselves - matters or decisions not provided for in the Treaty but arising from the existence of a single currency. The beginning of the third stage of EMU will clearly demand greater coordination of the Member States' economic policies. Monetary policy cannot be divorced from economic policy, and for that reason, such coordination is an essential requirement arising from the adoption of a single currency.

But in this area, we must take the greatest care over every detail and weave a very fine spun web, because these decisions may easily also affect other Member States and we must prevent a club for certain exclusive policies becoming an exclusive club for all policies.

There are formulas in existence which would allow us to achieve this, but I will not refer to them here.

oOo

I am sure you will agree that decisions on the major guidelines of the Union's economic policy cannot be taken behind the backs of our citizens. For that reason it is from every point of view essential that before deciding on the Commission's recommendation, the Council should consult the European Parliament, the institution which guarantees the full participation of the representatives of all the Member States in exercising control over decisions within the framework of EMU. And I mean all the Member States, without exception - the 'ins' participating in the third phase, the 'pre-ins' who will be perhaps joining at a later stage, and the 'outs'.

I should like to point out that I am not referring to decisions affecting monetary policy. Those decisions are to be taken quite independently by the European Central Bank. For that reason, Parliament has, in conjunction with the European Monetary Institute, been setting up a practical system whose basis is to be an annual report, with additional specific a posteriori report where necessary, when the importance of the decisions concerned requires this.

But the major guidelines which are to frame economic and budgetary policy are quite another matter. These are political decisions of the first magnitude. To report to Parliament a posteriori on these decisions, as the Treaty provides, is all very well, but it is not enough. Parliament must also be consulted beforehand. The Treaties leave it to the Council to decide on such consultation - which, from a democratic point of view, is inexcusable.

Parliament will under no circumstances wait for the Council to come and tell it what it has done before it delivers its opinion. It will make its voice heard in good time. But it would be preferable for Parliament's opinion to be drawn up in a climate of collaboration; Parliament's opinion should be the outcome of a system of consultation laid down beforehand, with all necessary guarantees that under no circumstances should it delay the Council's decision.

Mr President,

Allow me to now to turn to the question of the future enlargement of the European Union, an issue on which the European Parliament has recently adopted a resolution. Enlargement constitutes not only a historic occasion in determining the future of Europe, but also a great moment for the Union, since it will enrich its political and economic potential, bringing major advantages for the current Member States.

It is necessary that we remind ourselves of this fact, at a time when the trend is to stress the sacrifices which enlargement may involve, and to overlook the fact that all previous enlargements have meant undeniable benefits for the countries which already belonged to the Union, and not merely for the candidate countries.

Parliament has sought to stress that the European Union is open to all European countries which meet the accession criteria laid down at the Copenhagen Council and has, on the basis of an overwhelming majority, laid down an enlargement strategy focused on the following points:

  • the enlargement process should begin with a document concluded on a common basis with all the candidate countries, since all those countries which meet the Copenhagen criteria with regard to democracy, respect for human rights and the protection of minorities have the right to begin the reinforced accession and negotiation process simultaneously, a process which should begin, for all of them, at the beginning of 1998.
  • the preparatory work should associate all the countries of Central and Eastern Europe on an equal footing.
  • nonetheless, the length and speed of the negotiations may vary in terms of the internal development of the different countries, and for this reason, more intensive bilateral negotiations should take place with those countries which have made most progress.
  • likewise, annual assessments are necessary, allowing us to display flexibility with regard to the classification of the candidate countries, which is determined solely and purely by the results achieved, and which may be reviewed at anytime.

This scheme of things faithfully reflects Parliament's conviction that the decision to pre-select one group of countries is politically inappropriate, since it would create a fracture line that would result in a new kind of curtain between the candidate countries. Nor would such a decision be economically appropriate, since it would penalize the ability of Central and Eastern European countries not included in the pre-selection group to attract direct foreign investment.

An efficient and reliable public administration is an essential part of the preparations for European Union accession. The AGENDA 2000 Programme provides for very considerable funds to be made available to the first-wave countries which, without such an administration, would have difficulties in absorbing this funding, and which in any case would further penalize the countries not included in this first wave. And quite unnecessarily at that, since we all know the difficulties encountered when it comes to using the funding provided under the Phare Programme.

Furthermore, Parliament has once again stressed the need for prior institutional reform, as specified in its recent resolution on Amsterdam Treaty, and on the method to be used in order to achieve this reform. Such reform must, at all events, be achieved before the first enlargement takes place.

oOo

The European Conference, the setting up of which is to be decided today by Council, could be a useful instrument for political cooperation in the shape of multi-lateral dialogue on matters of common interest, providing the following prerequisites are met:

  • firstly, all European countries seeking accession, and which have Association Agreements with the Union, should participate,
  • secondly, the conference should be held on the basis of a specific programme reflecting the needs and concerns of the participating countries,
  • thirdly, the conference should not replace bilateral negotiations on enlargement nor entail the right to join the Union automatically by a fixed deadline,
  • finally, the conference should be held at least at the level of heads of state and of government, and with the participation of the Presidents of the European Parliament and the Commission. Given Parliament's powers with regard to accessions to the Union, its full participation at all levels of the Conference must be guaranteed.

This Conference could be the framework for the special high level relationship which Parliament wishes to see established between Turkey and the European Union, without prejudice to our repeatedly stated position that clear progress must be made with regard to human rights, democratic reforms, treatment of the Kurdish minority and the resolution of the problem of the occupation of northern Cyprus.

We are therefore talking about a strategy which could contain various levels of dialogue, a kind of Russian doll which contains smaller dolls, on the basis of each individual candidate country's degree of readiness for enlargement.

oOo

Furthermore, the future enlargement of the European Union will have financial implications, on which Parliament has adopted a very prudent and carefully weighed position, which may be summed up as follows:

  • the Commission forecast that 1.27% of GDP will be enough to fund enlargement is based on unacceptably random hypothesis, and it is therefore too early to establish a ceiling.
  • the new financial perspective must therefore be automatically revised whenever a new accession treaty is signed, and also if the possible reforms of the common agricultural policy and the Structural Funds system have not been implemented. Without adequate financial resources, these reforms could worsen the imbalances which already exist between the Union's richer and poorer regions.
  • it is also important to prevent the financial impact of enlargement from undermining the principles of solidarity and economic and social cohesion within the Union. Further enlargements cannot be carried out at the cost of jeopardizing the solidarity and cohesion policies and mechanisms with which the Union has equipped itself in order to ensure the wellbeing of all its citizens. Robbing Peter to pay Paul is not a viable option. It would be very rash, in terms of the future of our Union, to interrupt the enormous efforts being made to achieve solidarity just at the moment when we are beginning to see their first positive results.
  • the principle of 'just returns', as it is called, should also be excluded; what should be taken into account are all the budgetary and non-budgetary benefits which accrue from European integration.
  • the time has therefore come to display the political courage and the imagination required to revise the system of own-resources, by assessing the possibility of establishing a new system which will better reflect the relative prosperity of our citizens and, at the same time, be more visible to them.

Mr President,

The process of European Union enlargement is not a race which will be won by the fastest sprinter. It is must more like a marathon, when what matters is not winning the first few kilometres, but arriving at the finishing line in good shape. We are not talking so much about the speed of negotiations as about their quality - negotiations which will benefit all the citizens of the candidate countries. For that reason, it is important that the latter be clearly aware at one and the same time of the political will to welcome them into the Union as soon as possible, and of the need to avoid strange shortcuts which will nearly end up damaging their efforts.

The future enlargement of the Union to Central and Eastern Europe is a historic, political and moral duty. All the more reason then, that we carry out this enlargement in keeping with the general principle which guides and indeed justifies the whole process of European integration: namely that every individual must profit from what profits all, and that the benefits are shared by all in a spirit of solidarity.


© European Parliament: 1998